Advantages and Disadvantages of Including a Flawed Character in Your Story

Every story needs a character that readers can relate to. A flawed main character can make or break a story, bringing both advantages and disadvantages. Let's explore the pros and cons of incorporating a flawed character into your narrative, along with key tips on how to do it effectively.

The Advantages of a Flawed Character

1. Relatability: No one is perfect, and a flawed main character can be incredibly relatable. This connection helps readers empathize with the character and makes the story more impactful. For instance, a stock trader who is a genius quant and is making millions might seem like an ideal hero, but adding cocaine addiction, DUI, a failing marriage, and an SEC investigation can make the character more realistic and relatable.

2. Opportunities and Setbacks: Flaws can provide opportunities and create setbacks, making the story more dynamic. A brilliant strategist who loses his temper and enemies within the Emperor's circle can turn the plot into a thrilling rollercoaster ride. If the main character goes from Point A to Point B without facing any hindrances or setbacks, the story becomes predictable and boring.

3. Overcoming Flaws at Critical Moments: Flaws can also be used to create powerful moments of character transformation and growth. A swordsman who loses his sword arm can train again and "awaken" at a critical moment, overcoming his flaw and winning the battle. Similarly, an Empress with magical power but self-sacrifice issues can make readers question her actions, leading to a satisfying and emotionally engaging conclusion.

Challenges in Incorporating Flaws

1. Technical Complexity: Crafting a flawed character effectively requires skillful weaving of narrative elements. An author must ensure that the flaws are seamlessly integrated into the plot without making the story feel forced or convoluted. Mixing a cocaine addiction, DUI, relationship issues, and high-profile trades while ensuring a market crash is relevant and impactful can be challenging.

2. Consistent Consequences: Flaws must have consistent and meaningful consequences. A war general with a short temper who mouths off to the Emperor, his rivals, or subordinates should face repercussions. These consequences could include demotion, loss of respect, or even physical harm. Providing these consequences ensures that the character remains believable and relatable.

3. Avoiding Overdone Tropes: Some flaws can become clichés, making the character less original and compelling. A heroine who is abused by her parents and doesn't know how to love can feel unoriginal and unrelatable. Instead, consider exploring different dimensions of the character. A stock trader who is a terrible judge of character and makes bad decisions because of reliance on bad people can add a fresh perspective to the narrative.

Conclusion

The inclusion of a flawed character in your story can bring both advantages and disadvantages. When done skillfully, a flawed character can make your story more relatable, dynamic, and emotionally engaging. However, technical execution, consistent consequences, and avoiding overdone tropes are crucial to crafting a memorable and compelling narrative. Always strive to make your main character flawed and relatable, as this can distinguish your work from others and captivate your readers.

Key Takeaways: Relatability: A flawed character resonates with readers. Opportunities and Setbacks: Flaws create dynamic and engaging stories. Overcoming Flaws: Powerful moments of character growth enhance storytelling. Technical Complexity: Skillful weaving is necessary. Consistent Consequences: Meaningful and relatable flaws. Avoiding Tropes: Exploring unique dimensions of your character.