Would Olenna Tyrell Ever Agree to Margaery’s Marriage to Tyrion Lannister?

Would Olenna Tyrell Ever Agree to Margaery’s Marriage to Tyrion Lannister? This is a question that explores the complex political and personal dynamics within the realm of Westeros. The strategic mind of Olenna Tyrell, known for her sharp wit and pragmatism, would likely have viewed such a union with considerable skepticism. In this article, we delve into the reasons why Olenna might oppose the marriage and examine the broader context of her family's ambitions.

Olenna Tyrell’s Perspective

Olenna Tyrell, a formidable and shrewd political figure, would approach the suggestion of Margaery Tyrell marrying Tyrion Lannister with a keen eye on both her family's interests and her own personal views. While she is undoubtedly pragmatic, she would prioritize the well-being and power of House Tyrell.

The Perception of Tyrion

The first and foremost issue Olenna would face is the perception of Tyrion Lannister. She harbored a negative view of him due to his Lannister heritage and his dwarfism, which carries a stigma. Despite Tyrion's intelligence and political acumen, these factors would make him unsuitable in her eyes as a match for Margaery, who is an important asset for House Tyrell.

Strategic Calculations

In her strategic calculations, Olenna would weigh the potential political advantages against the risks. Given that Tywin Lannister's power is waning, a marriage to Tyrion might not provide the same political leverage as other potential alliances. Olenna would likely see other suitors, such as members of the Baratheon or Martell dynasties, as more advantageous for securing the Tyrell family's power and influence.

Margaery’s Ambitions

Margaery Tyrell is ambitious and seeks to elevate her status. Olenna would be concerned that a marriage to Tyrion might not align with her daughter's aspirations. Her ultimate goal for Margaery is to secure a more powerful and traditional match, such as Joffrey Baratheon or another strong alliance that offers greater prestige and security.

Existing Alliances

Olenna is already involved in a marriage alliance with the Lannisters through Margaery's engagement to Joffrey. The suggestion of marrying Margaery to Tyrion would be a significant departure from this established arrangement and could jeopardize their standing with the crown. Undermining these existing arrangements could have far-reaching consequences for the Tyrell family.

In Conclusion

While Olenna Tyrell is a skilled negotiator and could potentially agree to a marriage for the right reasons, it is unlikely she would view a union between Margaery and Tyrion favorably given her views on Tyrion and her family's ambitions. Her strategic mind and personal views make her hesitant to compromise the Tyrell family's interests.

Further Examining the Possibility

In the books
Nooo way. A house like the Tyrells would want the best, ie. Jamie or go for the next generation, ie. Joffrey/Tommen the king, even better.

Although tbh, it would make just as much sense as everything else that happened in seasons 7-8 of the show.

While the possibility of such a marriage existing in the books seems remote, the show's narrative often leaves room for unexpected alliances and shifts in power dynamics. Olenna Tyrell, with her understanding and adaptability, might have been open to such an arrangement if it served her family's interests, but such a union would likely face significant opposition and skepticism from her.