Would Isengard Defeat Mordor in an Open Battlefield?

When envisioning a battle scenario between Isengard and Mordor, it's essential to first understand their current states and the resources they command. With the strength of Elrond and the dwindling numbers of the elves, rivendell might hold its ground, but this article primarily focuses on the sheer might of Isengard and Mordor.

Estimating the Power of Isengard and Mordor

The decision of which side would win hinges on the strategic and numerical advantages each side holds. Rivendell, under Elrond's leadership, is probably the second strongest due to its powerful military position, while Lothlórien, with Galadriel leading, stands as the strongest. However, Mirkwood would occupy the rearguard, and Isengard would be the leading force.

It's a close call, but if we're to imagine a battle where Isengard and Mordor meet on an open battlefield, the orcs of Isengard would likely win due to their increased numbers after the rise of Sauron's orcs. The Elves are strong but their dwindling numbers make the battle even more challenging. Regardless of their strength, their numbers without further augmentation would be insufficient.

Strategic Considerations: Open Battlefield versus Fixed Fortresses

Considering the strategic backdrop of Middle-earth, it's unrealistic to imagine a direct confrontation on an open battlefield due to the fixed positions of Isengard and Mordor. Both fortresses are too well-established for such a scenario. However, the possibility of remote warfare, such as ballistic missiles and aerial bombardment, comes into play.

Unfortunately, the Middle-earth setting does not provide much support for ballistics, except for counterweight catapults with limited range. Hence, aerial bombardment emerges as the main option. It's possible Sauron had flying creatures capable of striking enemy positions, but given the presence of eagles and their neutrality, the advantage still lies with Sauron. Meanwhile, Isengard retains only a handful of defenses, making it vulnerable.

The War of Numbers and Power

From a purely numerical and power standpoint, Isengard stands no chance against Mordor. Isengard, the fortress once belonging to the Dúnedain and now under the control of Saruman, has a strategic advantage with its towering Orthanc. However, the sheer numbers and versatility of Mordor surpass Isengard's might dramatically.

Mordor, led by the Dark Lord Sauron, boasts tens of thousands of orcs and even more in reserves. Barad-d?r, the main fortress of Mordor, is a towering structure that could hold hundreds of thousands of orcs. The strength of Sauron's forces, combined with the fallen Istar (forty wizards), and other powerful allies, makes every engagement between the two areas virtually a slaughter.

Isengard's chances of victory against Mordor are slim. The battle pits a fortress against a whole dark country, a mismatch so obvious it requires no further elaboration. While a conflict between Isengard and Barad-d?r would be a more sensible match, it still results in a lopsided battle in favor of Mordor.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Isengard could never hope to survive, let alone win an all-out battle against Mordor. Even a confrontation with the primary fortress, Barad-d?r, would be a severe challenge. Understanding the power dynamics of Elven forces and the overwhelming might of Mordor highlights the impossibility of any victory for Isengard in such a scenario.