Why Some Poorly Written Novels Become Bestsellers: An Analysis

It can be frustrating to see poorly written novels achieving bestseller status while more beautifully crafted works fail to gain traction. This phenomenon is often perplexing, but there are several factors at play that explain this discrepancy. In this article, we will explore why some poorly written novels can become bestsellers, while others, despite their literary merits, struggles to find an audience.

A Deeper Look into Poorly Written Bestsellers

Poorly written novels that become bestsellers often possess certain qualities that resonate with readers, such as interesting plot hooks and a fast pace. These qualities often overshadow the prose deficiencies that may be present in the writing. Identifiable and relatable characters are another trait that can help propel a novel to the top of bestseller lists. Additionally, these books often tap into commonly held feelings or emotions, which can make them more accessible and appealing to a wide audience.

Different Reader Preferences and Expectations

It's important to remember that different readers look for different things in a book. While literary quality is highly valued by critics and some readers, the average reader is often more concerned with the plot and character development. They are less focused on the prose style and more interested in how the story unfolds and how the characters evolve. Protagonists who are easy to identify with or plots that captivate readers are key factors in the success of a book, regardless of the quality of the writing.

Market vs. Critical Success

Artistic quality and mass popularity are two distinct concepts that seldom go hand in hand. This can be observed in the film industry as well, where critically acclaimed movies often do not perform as well at the box office. For example, the movie with the highest Metascore on Metacritic this year is Aftersun, which has grossed only $1.5 million worldwide. The second-highest rated movie has only seven reviews, and the third-highest is Tár, which has earned $5.25 million. In contrast, the top-grossing movie of the year is Top Gun: Maverick, which has earned almost $1.5 billion, yet its Metascore is only 78, ranking it 86th for the year. Similarly, Jurassic World: Dominion made $1 billion but has a Metascore of 38, which places it at 493rd for the year. Audiences often seek different elements in a story that critics may overlook.

Conclusion and Takeaways

In conclusion, the popularity of a book is not solely determined by its literary quality. Plot hooks, character development, and emotional resonance can all contribute to a book’s appeal, regardless of the writing quality. Understanding these factors can help authors, publishers, and readers better appreciate the diverse elements that contribute to a book's success. Whether a book is poorly written but a bestseller or beautifully crafted but not widely read, it is important to recognize the unique qualities that make each work appealing to its specific audience.