Why Some Might Hate Robert A. Heinlein and His Books

Robert A. Heinlein is widely regarded as one of the most influential authors in science fiction, with a reputation for captivating readers through his imaginative plots and deep characters. Yet, he is not without his critics. This article explores the reasons why some individuals might dislike Heinlein and his works, highlighting specific books and their controversial aspects.

Success and Controversy: A Complex Relationship

One of the primary reasons why some people might find Heinlein irksome is primarily due to the element of success. Heinlein's success in the literary world was remarkable, and it often seems to rouse envy and resentment in some quarters.

Heinlein was known for his assertive stance on the publishing rights of his books, scrambling to ensure his work was not overshadowed or altered by others. In a time when the idea of an author controlling their own intellectual property was radical, Heinlein's activism in this area stood out. His boldness did not go unappreciated, but it also did not make him friends with everyone who came in contact with him or his work.

Controversial Elements in Heinlein’s Work

One of the most criticized works by Heinlein is "Starship Troopers," often mistaken for a political statement about fascism. While the book does explore themes of militarism and national service, many readers interpret it through a lens of fascist ideology, which is a misunderstanding borne out of its controversial moments and the political landscape of the time. However, it is essential to note that Heinlein was a complex figure, and his works should be read and interpreted with the lens of his time and writing philosophy in mind.

Other Contenders for Controversy: "The Number of the Beast"

Aside from "Starship Troopers," "The Number of the Beast" is another book that invites criticism. The novel is adept at jumping between various situations without offering a clear resolution, which can leave readers feeling unsatisfied. This narrative technique may alienate some readers who prefer a more linear plot structure and a well-reasoned progression of events.

Patriotism and "Stranger in a Strange Land"

Heinlein's writings often tackled themes of authority and power. His views on patriotism can be contentious, particularly his controversial line, "Kill a commie for mommie," which reflects his often strident stance against communism. The "bugs" in "Starship Troopers" are a metaphor for communist forces, presenting a vivid and unsettling description of the enemy. This imagery is not for the faint of heart and can be disturbing to readers whose beliefs are firmly against such aggressive rhetoric.

The Most Controversial Book: "Stranger in a Strange Land"

Among Heinlein's works, "Stranger in a Strange Land" is perhaps the most contentious. This novel, which explores themes of religion, sex, and rebellion, has been a target for controversy since its publication. It is often criticized for mixing sex and religion, which can be seen as a direct challenge to traditional values and religious dogma. Heinlein's ability to explore these themes in a way that is both thought-provoking and accessible has made "Stranger in a Strange Land" a particular bone of contention for those who hold strict religious beliefs.

Furthermore, the book's celebration of the human spirit, even in its flawed nature, has been seen by some as a critique of the establishment and a support for the rise of certain political movements. Its perceived role in nurturing the religious right as a political force in America adds another layer to its controversy, making it a challenging read for a significant portion of the population.

So, while Robert A. Heinlein remains a revered figure in the science fiction community, his works are not without their detractors. His success in controlling his intellectual property, the political and social implications of his books, and his sometimes controversial viewpoints all contribute to why some individuals might find his work difficult to appreciate or even loathe.