Why I Dislike Superheroes Without Superpowers and Their Exaggerated Capabilities

It's fascinating to observe the inclination of writers to compensate for the lack of extraordinary abilities in superheroic humans with unrealistic and inhuman feats. This practice often undermines the relatability and authenticity of such characters, failing to deliver the intended message of their ordinary yet heroic nature. One prime example is the character of Batman.

Technically, Batman's abilities are attributed to mere peak human physical prowess, perhaps enhanced by steroids. Nonetheless, his strength and agility often border on the inhuman. Bat kicks, punches, and strikes with forces that make little sense in a realistic context. His resilience in absorbing blows is equally exaggerated; he endures serious challenges while seemingly unscathed. This inconsistency weakens the believability of his character and the overall narrative.

I embrace Batman's admirable character, particularly in his unwavering commitment to justice without crossing the line into criminality. However, I find this portrayal problematic. Pretending Batman is an ordinary human when he displays such extraordinary feats is not only misleading but also detracts from the thematic integrity of his story. His over-the-top capabilities call into question his relatability, making it difficult for readers to identify with his journey.

It's crucial to emphasize the limitations and vulnerabilities of non-powered heroes. Characters like Rorschach from V Watch serve as prime examples. Rorschach's strength and stamina are human-like, and he struggles to stand against true superhumans like Doctor Manhattan. In fact, in his encounter with Ozymandias, Rorschach is outmatched, showcasing the stark contrast between regular humans and beings with godly powers. This portrayal maintains a healthy level of authenticity, making the story more compelling and thought-provoking.

Ned Leeds: A Deeper Hero with Human Limitations

A different approach to non-powered heroes is seen in characters like Ned Leeds from the Spectacular Spider-Man series. Ned embodies heroism through his human skills and efforts to support Peter Parker without resorting to superhuman abilities. His strengths lie in his fallsible human qualities, making him a relatable hero who helps Peter remain grounded in his everyday life. This portrayal of a human hero is far more compelling because it demonstrates that ordinary people can achieve extraordinary results with their ordinary skills.

Conclusion: Preserving Relatability in Non-Powered Heroes

In conclusion, the inclusion of non-powered heroes in superhero narratives is a critical aspect of maintaining the relatability and authenticity of such characters. When these heroes are endowed with unrealistic feats and capabilities, the stories become less believable and the thematic depth diminishes. Instead, characters like Rorschach and Ned Leeds serve as reminders of the true power of human determination and resilience. Ultimately, emphasizing the ordinary yet heroic aspects of non-powered heroes contributes to a richer and more engaging narrative.