Introduction

James C. Gardner, a renowned fantasy novelist, often explores alternative timelines in his writings. What if Frodo Baggins succumbed to the corrupting influence of the One Ring at the very moment he was about to destroy it? This article delves into the potential consequences of such a scenario, exploring its impact on Middle-earth and the pivotal role of the Ringwraiths in shaping the narrative's outcome.

The Fall of Frodo

Imagine a scene from The Lord of the Rings where, instead of Gollum, it is Frodo who grabs the ring and strangles his faithful companion. Frodo's transformation into a Ringwraith, unhinged by the corrupting influence of the One Ring, could alter the course of the entire series. Gollum, driven by his insatiable desire for the Ring, would still be alive and eventually serve as a catalyst for tragic events in Middle-earth.

A Darker Quest

If Frodo had taken the Ring and become a Ringwraith, the quest to destroy it would have likely failed. This shift could have resulted in a darker and more desperate struggle for the remaining free peoples of Middle-earth as they faced a corrupted Frodo, now wielding the Ring’s dark power. The narrative would no longer revolve around the eventual triumph of good over evil but instead focus on the descent of Frodo into darkness and the loss of hope for the free peoples of Middle-earth.

Escalating Chaos and Destruction

As Frodo’s transformation into a Ringwraith becomes apparent, Sauron would quickly grasp the opportunity to regain control through his most loyal servant. The Nazgul, now with a newly corrupted Ringwraith acting on their behalf, would launch an even more effective campaign to subdue Middle-earth. The realms of Rohan, Gondor, and others would face an unprecedented threat as the dark lord’s influence spread throughout the land.

Tragic Consequences

With Frodo now under Sauron’s control, the narrative would shift to a more tragic and dystopian tale. The destruction of the Ring could no longer serve as the central focus, but rather Frodo’s betrayal and the subsequent triumph of darkness. The return of the Ring to Sauron would mark the beginning of a new era of oppression where the free peoples of Middle-earth would struggle to find hope.

Conclusion

The hypothetical scenario of Frodo becoming a Ringwraith is a fascinating exploration of Middle-earth's potential dark future. It challenges the reader's understanding of the heroic journey and highlights the corrupting influence of power, even amongst those who are initially seen as virtuous. This alternate narrative not only deepens the reader's appreciation of Tolkien's work but also serves as a reminder of the importance of moral integrity in the face of great temptation.