Understanding the Question and Setting the Context

Someone is asking a rather intriguing “what if” question: ‘What would Aragorn have been like if he had not married Eowyn?’ However, the question contains some factual errors, which need to be addressed first. Tolkien’s world is clear, and Faramir is the one who married Eowyn, not Eomer who is Eowyn’s brother. This is important because changing the relationships in Middle-earth would have significant implications on the narrative and characters involved.

The Historical Inconsistencies and Factual Errors

It is crucial to verify the facts before questioning. In the context of Tolkien’s Middle-earth, the books and movies are the definitive sources. The prompt generator needs to ensure accuracy by referring to these works. For instance, Faramir and Eowyn are siblings from Gondor, and they fall in love and marry each other. Any mention of Eomer and Eowyn married would be incorrect, as it goes against the established lore.

The Impact of Eowyn’s Love for Faramir

The Return of the King clearly states that Eowyn and Faramir are married. This union leads to Faramir becoming the Steward of Gondor and the Lord of Ithilien. If Eowyn had not married Faramir, her life would likely have taken a different path. She was a capable leader, taking over as Regent of Rohan during Theoden’s absence and leading the Rohirrim valiantly to fight in the War of the Ring.

The Personal Life of Aragorn

Aragorn, as the rightful heir to the throne of Gondor, would have faced a different emotional and personal life. Tolkien initially planned for Aragorn and Eowyn to be together, but this plan was altered, leading to Arwen’s introduction. Eowyn’s presence would have been absent from his future, which would have significantly affected Aragorn's life.

The Social and Emotional Impact

After Aragorn was crowned King of Gondor, he would have lived for another 122 years. However, Eowyn was a mortal woman, and her lifespan could not match Aragorn’s. Her death would have left a profound void in Aragorn’s life. Instead, he would have been a widower for a considerable period, potentially dealing with feelings of loneliness and loss.

The Role of Eowyn and Arwen in the Narrative

Compared to Eowyn, who was driven by freedom and adventure, Aragorn’s queen might have been more constrained. Eowyn’s desire for freedom and her actions, such as deserting her position as Regent to fight in war, indicate that she would not have been content as a queen. She was meant to be a warrior, not a constrained royal figure.

On the other hand, Arwen was an immortal Elf, and her role in the story was to provide a connection between the mortal world and the elven realm. Her presence in Aragorn’s life added a layer of mystique and provided a lasting bond with the elves. If Eowyn had been the queen, Arwen would have lived a lonely life as Aragorn’s wife, eventually dying of grief and loneliness.

Alternative Scenarios and Their Impact

Imagine a scenario where Aragorn did not marry Eowyn. Instead, he might have married someone else, or perhaps never married at all. This scenario would drastically alter the narrative, affecting not only Aragorn’s personal life but also the political landscape of Middle-earth. Aragorn would have to find another way to lead Gondor and face the challenges that came with it.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the absence of Eowyn in Aragorn’s life would have significantly impacted the narrative, his personal life, and the political landscape of Middle-earth. While the original story provides a beautiful and tragic tale of love, it is important to appreciate the facts as established by Tolkien’s works. Understanding the relationships and the characters’ roles is crucial to fully appreciate the depth and complexity of Middle-earth.