Unrealistic Submarine Operations in the Movie Crimson Tide: An Analysis of Command Procedure

In the movie Crimson Tide, the scene where the two commanders remain on the deck while the submarine dives raises some realistic concerns. In actual submarine operations, it is standard procedure for the commanding officers to be in the control room or conn during critical maneuvers like diving. This practice is important for safety, communication, quick decision-making, and emergency procedures. This article delves into these aspects and analyzes why the scene in the movie is unrealistic.

Safety Protocols

Submarines operate in a complex environment where changes in depth and pressure can be dangerous. The control room is equipped with advanced monitoring systems that provide real-time information on the submarine's systems, depth, and external conditions. Having the commanding officers in the control room allows them to respond immediately to any issues that arise. This is particularly crucial during critical maneuvers such as diving, where the slightest misstep can lead to catastrophic consequences.

Communication

The control room is the nerve center of submarine operations. This is where the crew receives and processes real-time data, and where critical communications take place. Being away from this area could significantly hinder effective communication during critical moments. Quick and precise command and control are essential for the efficient operation of the submarine. The presence of commanding officers in the control room ensures that decision-making processes are streamlined and executed with minimal latency.

Decision Making

Quick decisions may be necessary during the diving process, especially if unforeseen circumstances arise. Having all key personnel, including the commanding officers, in the control room allows for better coordination and faster decision-making. This is particularly important in a high-stress environment where every second counts. The control room serves as a central hub for issuing and receiving commands, ensuring that every member of the crew is aware of the latest status and can act accordingly.

Emergency Procedures

The efficient handling of emergencies is critical for the safety of the submarine and its crew. In the event of an emergency such as taking on water or a mechanical failure, having the commanding officers in the control room can be a matter of life and death. Delays in response can compromise safety and increase the risk of harm. The presence of commanding officers in the control room ensures that any emergency can be handled swiftly and effectively, protecting the lives of the crew and ensuring the integrity of the vessel.

A Realistic Interpretation of Modern Submarine Operations

The scene in the movie Crimson Tide does not accurately reflect modern submarine operational procedures. In reality, both commanding officers would typically be present in the control room to ensure safety and effective management during a dive. This is especially true for modern US submarines, which do not have the same operational requirements as World War II submarines. The latter often had to surface for long periods due to the need for deck guns and air supply, making it necessary for commanding officers to be on the surface. However, modern submarines, with their sophisticated safety systems and streamlined operations, do not rely as heavily on surface operations.

Conclusion

While the scene in Crimson Tide adds dramatic tension to the film, it does not accurately reflect standard submarine operational procedures. In reality, both commanding officers would typically be present in the control room to ensure safety and effective management during a dive. This practice is essential for maintaining the highest standards of operational safety and efficiency. A better understanding of these procedures can help bridge the gap between the exciting narrative of movies and the intricate realities of submarine operations.