Understanding and Addressing Judgments in Civil Cases: Can a Judge Set Aside a Judgment?

Introduction to Judgments in Civil Cases

In a civil case with a jury, a judge can set aside a jury award by way of a judgment notwithstanding the verdict (JNOV). This concept is crucial in understanding the dynamics between judges, juries, and the legal processes they follow.

The Role of Judges in Setting Aside Verdicts

While a judge cannot simply set aside a verdict and force a mistrial in a civil case, they do retain the authority to issue a judgment notwithstanding the verdict (JNOV) if it is deemed that there is no evidence to support the jury's decision. Once a judgment is issued, the trial court typically loses jurisdiction over the case, except in matters related to sentencing or enforcement.

Humanizing the Judge’s Perspective

The experiences and perspectives of judges are as diverse and dynamic as those of any individual. Judges, like any other human being, are subject to change, and with change comes the potential to reconsider past judgments. By stepping into the shoes of those they judge, judges can better understand their actions and the context in which they occurred.

The Real Battle: Judging Ourselves vs. Judging Others

While it is true that judgments never entirely go away, they are ever-evolving. The personal experience and reflections of a judge highlight the complexity in judging others and oneself. Reflecting on past decisions, a judge might feel “mortified”?by earlier judgements, but these feelings can lead to a greater understanding and potential change in perspective. This is a lesson that applies to all of us: we are often more of a danger to ourselves than to others.

Final Thoughts on Addressing Judgments

No matter the context or the individual, the existence of judgment is a fact of life. While judgments may not go away, there are strategies for dealing with their impact. Learning to let go of judgmental thinking and focusing on constructive, empathetic interaction can foster a healthier and more harmonious environment for all.