Tolkien and the Ainur: Insights into Eru’s Perception of Humanity

Introduction

The relationship between J.R.R. Tolkien and the Ainur, particularly concerning his works and the enlightened being Eru Ilúvatar, is a fascinating topic that has intrigued scholars and fans alike for decades. Eru Ilúvatar, as the supreme being in Tolkien's Middle-earth universe, has a profound connection with the Ainur and all sentient beings. This article explores the possibility of Eru's awareness of Tolkien himself and his works, delving into the philosophical underpinnings of Tolkien's creation.

Understanding the Role of Tolkien in Middle-earth

Tolkien's works, such as the Legendarium, draw heavily from ancient knowledge and folklore, including Irish, Welsh, Finnish, and Norwegian mythologies. He aimed to revive and honor these ancient traditions, weaving them into a cohesive and compelling narrative. By preserving and bringing to life these forgotten cultures, Tolkien sought to reconnect people with their ancestral roots and the scholarly spirit that defined them.

The use of languages, place names, and mythological creatures from these cultures is not mere whimsical creativity but a conscious effort to maintain and revitalize a shared heritage. Tolkien's scholarship and deep respect for these mythological traditions contribute to a rich and detailed Middle-earth, providing a framework for exploring ancient wisdom and cultural identity.

The Philosophical Foundations of Tolkien's Creation

The foundation of Tolkien's works lies in the philosophical theories of his time, particularly the works of St. Thomas Aquinas and the theory of gradation. According to Aquinas, the universe operates on a principle of ordered diversity, where every element, no matter how small or large, has its place and purpose within a grand design.

Eru Ilúvatar, as the prime mover and orchestrator of this cosmos, allows for the gradation of existence. This means that while there is a divine order, there is also room for individual creativity and development. This concept aligns with the Theory of Unification (TOE), which suggests that all aspects of the universe, from the subatomic to the macroscopic, operate under a unifying principle of creation, communication, cooperation, and constancy.

From this perspective, Eru's perception of Tolkien and his works is not surprising. As an author who demonstrates the creative potential of free will within a designed system, Tolkien's writings are a natural outcome of the universe's inherent characteristics. Eru would not be surprised by the existence of a man like Tolkien, who taps into the ancient knowledge and mythologies to create a new, yet deeply-rooted, narrative.

Eru’s Clarity and Clairvoyance

The question of whether Eru had a clairvoyant vision of a Tolkien-like man existing in Ea (Middle-earth) is complex. While Eru Ilúvatar created the universe with a divine foresight, it is also conceivable that he allowed for the unpredictability of free will within his design. Tolkien, as an individual who embodies the qualities of creativity and scholarly spirit, would be an expected and natural figure within this framework.

Furthermore, the creative output of an author like Tolkien would be seen as a logical manifestation of the universe's potential for storytelling and cultural expression. The concept of revealing truths through stories and the power of language, which is a central theme in Tolkien's works, ties directly into the broader theme of communication and cooperation within Middle-earth.

Conclusion

The relationship between Eru Ilúvatar, the Ainur, and J.R.R. Tolkien is a rich and multifaceted one. Tolkien's works, drawing from ancient mythologies and languages, serve to revitalize and honor these traditions. Philosophically, his creativity aligns with the principles of gradation and unification, suggesting that his existence and works are not surprising to Eru Ilúvatar. The clairvoyance of Eru in predicting the emergence of Tolkien-type figures is a testament to the depth of his foresight and the intricate design of the universe he created.