Introduction

Imagine a world where Sauron triumphed in the War of the Ring. How would Middle-earth look different, and would his victory have implications for Bilbo's possession of the One Ring? This article explores the alternate reality where Sauron becomes the God-King, and whether his interests in the ring would be the same or different.

The Fall of Middle-earth

Assuming Sauron won the War of the Ring around 70 years after The Hobbit, the immediate outcome for Middle-earth would likely replicate the events and consequences described in the original story. However, the long-term scenario would look vastly different. Sauron's victory would mean Middle-earth's inhabitants would have to submit to him as a God-King. (Keyword: Middle-earth)

Submission and Worship

Under Sauron's rule, Middle-earth would experience absolute submission and worship. The extreme nature of his rule would entail strict adherence to “perfection,” leading to a society devoid of war, plague, or famine. Yet, this utopia would be constructed in a way that is incompatible with free living peoples. Sauron, driven by his narcissistic perfectionism, would maintain absolute control. (Keyword: Sauron)

Eldar and Númenóreans

Despite Sauron's presence, two significant groups would not conform to his rule. The Elves would leave Middle-earth, pursuing their own destiny or facing the threat of Sauron, which they would eventually defy. Likewise, the Númenóreans, represented by the Men, would continue to exist outside of Sauron's immediate sphere of influence. This suggests a spark of resistance amidst his reign. (Keyword: Elves)

The One Ring and Renewed Threats

However, Sauron's victory might not be permanent. If he regains physical possession of the One Ring, the hidden strengths and weaknesses of his followers become apparent. Without the One Ring, Sauron's influence would weaken but not entirely disappear. The Vanishing of the Elves and the diminished status of the Dwarves suggest a gradual decline, although not an immediate one. (Keyword: One Ring)

The Valar's Intervention

As the legend foretells, the Valar, the powerful beings in Arda, face a moral dilemma when confronted with the reality of killing the children of their creator to end Sauron. The cost of such an intervention is immeasurable and fraught with moral and ethical challenges. Yet, the Valar, fearing Sauron's potential for an all-out scorched earth campaign, might be compelled to intervene. (Keyword: Valar)

The Final Stand

The final confrontation between the Valar and Sauron would be a grim contest of wills and power. If the Valar were to intervene, they would face the ultimate choice: sacrifice the lives of countless Men to defeat Sauron, or face the terrifying prospect of the Void. Eru, the supreme being, might be required to step in, intervening in a way that both defeats Sauron and addresses the cosmic balance. (Keyword: Eru)

Conclusion

The hypothetical scenario of a victorious Sauron on Middle-earth paints a grim picture of a meticulously controlled yet utterly oppressive society. Despite the arguable virtues of his rule, the existential threat posed by humanity and the necessary intervention of the Valar underscore the complexity and profound nature of the conflict in Middle-earth. This alternate reality offers a rich tapestry of moral and philosophical dilemmas, inviting readers to ponder the true cost of victory.