The Tragedy of E?l the Dark Elf: A Legendarium Character Study

In J.R.R. Tolkien's expansive legendarium, the term Moriquendi represents those Elves who refused the summons to the ?blessed lands of Aman. Among the Moriquendi stands a notable figure, E?l the Dark Elf, a tragic character whose actions and fate are marked by darkness and the pursuit of power. Let's delve into the specifics of his story and his impact on the legendarium.

The Origins and Role of Moriquendi

The Moriquendi, or Avari, are marked by their choice not to seek the light of Aman, the western paradise, while the some of them, like the Sindar (Grey Elves), made a partial journey but did not reach the blessed isles. These Elves lived in the shadow of the more favored Calaquendi or "Children of the Light, " who journeyed to Aman.

E?l the Dark Elf: A Notable Figure Among the Moriquendi

E?l is a Noldorin Elf, one of the most surprising and compelling figures among the Moriquendi. He dwells in the dark forests of Middle-earth, particularly in Nan Elmoth. His character is defined by his connection to darkness and metallurgy, not in the sense of negativity but as a deeply intrinsic part of his being.

E?l is best known for his exceptional skills in crafting weapons and armor, and his most infamous creation, the black sword Anglachel, forged from meteoric iron. This sword, which later became a symbol of both power and tragedy, showcases E?l's dark but profound craftsmanship.

Key Events Involving E?l

Marrying Aredhel

In a notable sequence of events, E?l captures Aredhel, the daughter of Turgon, and they marry. However, Aredhel's love for freedom is strong, and she eventually escapes from E?l's control, marking the beginning of a tragic journey for her and her son Maeglin.

Conflict with the Sons of Aredhel

E?l's pursuit of Aredhel and her son leads him to Gondolin, where he challenges the inhabitants and discovers his ex-wife and son. The tension and conflict culminate in a confrontation with the inhabitants of Gondolin, ultimately leading to E?l's capture and trial.

Fate

Upon trial, E?l is found guilty of his illegal and dangerous actions. The inhabitants of Gondolin offer him two choices: exile or death by being cast into the abyss. E?l chooses the latter, symbolically joining the darkness he has always been associated with, demonstrating his unwillingness to embrace the light.

The Fate of the Dark Elves

The Moriquendi like E?l often lived in the shadow of the more powerful Calaquendi. They were depicted as living in contrast to the more fortunate and blessed Elves who sought and found light in Aman. Over time, these Elves, including E?l, became entangled in the conflicts of Middle-earth, often in opposition to the forces of good and light.

The Dark Elves represent a complex and often tragic aspect of Tolkien's world, embodying themes of loss, darkness, and the consequences of choices made in defiance of the light. Their portrayal offers a rich tapestry of emotions and moral dilemmas, inviting readers and scholars to ponder the nature of power, choice, and the struggle between darkness and light.