The Tragedy at Summerhall and the Myth of The Doom of Valyria

The Targaryen family has a tragic and compelling history, particularly highlighted by the mysterious events at Summerhall. These occurrences (Summerhall) have piqued the interest of many due to the involvement of dragon eggs and an apparent attempt to revive the dragon lineage. This essay delves into the details surrounding this tragic incident and whether it has any connection to the Doom of Valyria.

The Tragedy at Summerhall

The summer of the dragon Aegon V Targaryen (also known as Aegon the Unworthy) saw his obsession with dragons come to a tragic crescendo at Summerhall. Aegon’s brothers, Aerion and Aemon, each possessed a dragon egg, and the first great-grandchild of Aerys II Targaryen and Rhaella Targaryen was also a symbol of Aegon’s hopes for dragons.

On the actual day in 259 AC, Aegon called upon many of his family members to gather at Summerhall to celebrate the birth of this grandchild. However, his true intention was to hatch dragon eggs before anyone else. The atmosphere was charged with excitement and anticipation, but unfortunately, it ended in a disastrous fire that claimed the lives of Aegon, his son Duncan, and Ser Duncan the Tall.

Post-Accident Reflections

One of the survivors, Archmaester Gyldayn, documented the event in the History of House Targaryen. His account paints a vivid picture of the panicked chaos that unfolded:

The blood of the dragon gathered in one… seven eggs to honor the seven gods though the king’s own septon had warned… pyromancers… wildfire… flames grew out of control… towering… burned so hot that… died but for the valor of the Lord Commander…

The fire, fueled by prohibitions and forbidden knowledge, proved too uncontrollable. The dragon eggs not only failed to turn into dragons but also resulted in the tragic loss of Aegon and his loved ones.

The Doom of Valyria: A Disaster of Different Proportions

While the tragedy at Summerhall is shrouded in uncertainty and suspense, the Doom of Valyria was a cataclysmic event unlike any other. According to lore, the Doom was caused by the eruption of the 14 volcanoes of Valyria simultaneously, along with the interference of the Faceless Men. This event completely obliterated the history and legacy of the Targaryens' predecessors.

It’s important to note that the Doom and the tragedy at Summerhall are distinctly separate events. While neither can be completely understood due to the rich tapestry of lore and legend surrounding them, the Doom of Valyria is a historical event with roots in the upheaval of Valyria and its volcanic eruption.

Speculation and Mythology

Over the years, theories have emerged suggesting that the Summerhall tragedy was not a mere accident but a failed attempt to resurrect dragons, which ties into the broader tapestry of dragon lore in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire. Interestingly, the period surrounding these events includes several stories and legends that cast shadows of doubt on the traditional narrative.

However, all these speculations must be met with caution. The Doom of Valyria is firmly grounded in the historical context of volcanic eruptions and the influence of the Faceless Men, making it a distinct and unique event.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

The tragedy at Summerhall and the Doom of Valyria, while both linked to the Targaryen family and their heritage, are isolated events with their own narratives and causes. The tragedy at Summerhall speaks to the fatal consequences of obsession and curiosity, while the Doom of Valyria represents the monumental destruction of a civilization.

Further research and scholarly analysis are needed to uncover the full extent of these events, but for now, we can appreciate the richness of these stories in the context of medieval fantasy.