The Pros and Cons of Sharing Your Manuscript Before Publication: Insights from a Writer

Every author knows the importance of sharing their work with others before publication. While some share their manuscripts for feedback, others use them for personal proofreading. In this piece, we explore the benefits and drawbacks of this practice, providing insights from a seasoned writer.

The Art of Proofreading

Proofreading your manuscript is not just about catching spelling and grammatical errors. It's also about ensuring the story is engaging and easy to follow. Before the final draft, it's crucial to get feedback on the flow and readability of your work. As a writer, I often seek out individuals who can help me refine my story, whether it's a fellow writer, a relative, or a close friend. They act as my proof readers, ensuring that any rough patches in the narrative are identified and fixed.

Why Share Your Manuscript Early?

Sharing your manuscript can be incredibly beneficial. First and foremost, it allows you to catch any mistakes that might have been overlooked during the editing process. Even the most thorough editor can sometimes miss errors. Additionally, it helps you gauge the overall readability of your story. If there are parts of the narrative that are confusing or hard to follow, you can make adjustments before final publication.

Early Feedback/Testing Readers

Some individuals, like my brother, can become your testing readers. These readers give you immediate feedback on the story's flow and content. For instance, during a random car trip, my brother listened to my non-stop narrative for my first book, laying the groundwork for it. This kind of feedback ensures that the story makes sense and resonates with the intended audience.

Choosing the Right Readers

Not just any individual can serve as a proofreader. You need to choose readers who are avid and experienced. They should have a keen eye for detail and be able to provide constructive criticism. Someone who takes weeks or months to read a book won't be helpful for getting timely feedback. I encountered this issue when a relative took two years to get back to me after the book was published!

Handling Controversial Content

Sharing your manuscript comes with certain risks, especially if the content is controversial or sensitive. For example, if you write erotic or controversial content, it might not sit well with family members. Your proof readers should be trustworthy and understanding. For instance, if you share a story that includes family secrets or negative depictions, it might strain relationships.

Selecting the Right Audience

It's also important to consider the preferences of those you choose to share your manuscript with. I have a friend who doesn't enjoy reading science fiction or fantasy. Despite this, he still reads my manuscripts and provides valuable feedback. His positive response tells me that I have a good story on my hands. Similarly, if your readers enjoy the genre you write in, it can boost your confidence as a writer.

Online Resources for Preliminary Feedback

If you're hesitant to share your manuscript with people you know, there are online resources that can help. Many websites offer communities of readers and writers who are eager to read early drafts. Some even sell advance reader copies of manuscripts. Readers are willing to pay for pre-publication copies to experience the work in its rawest form. This practice not only helps you get feedback but also allows you to engage with a dedicated fanbase.

Conclusion

While sharing your manuscript with others can be a double-edged sword, the benefits often outweigh the risks. It's important to find the right balance and choose the right readers. Whether it's a close friend, a testing reader, or an online community, the feedback you receive can significantly improve your work.

Happy Writing!

Remember, every great writer started somewhere. Share your work, learn from the feedback, and keep improving. Best of luck on your writing journey!