The Impact of Elrond's Tackle: A Hypothetical Scenario and Its Consequences

What if the scenario in which Elrond tackled Isildur into Mount Doom were to transpire? This hypothetical scenario poses a significant question: What would happen if Elrond, the wiry Elf-lord, was able to physically disarm and toss the heavily armored and possessed Isildur into the volcano? Let's explore the potential consequences of such an event.

No Such Scene Actually Occurred

To begin with, it is essential to clarify that no such scene actually occurred in the texts or films. The closest approximation was the aftermath of the Battle of Dagorlad, where a battle took place outside Mount Doom. After the battle, Isildur showed the ring to Elrond, who advised him to destroy it, pointing to the volcano as an ideal location. However, they never actually approached the volcano or the Crack of Doom. Isildur decided to keep the ring out of respect for his father and his line.

The Hypothetical Scenario Explained

Imagine this hypothetical scenario: Elrond, with incredible willpower and physical prowess, overpowers Isildur and tosses him into Mount Doom. Firstly, Isildur's possession by the Ring of Power necessitates tremendous force to overcome. Tolkien explicitly stated in his works that not even Sauron himself could destroy the Ring by force of will alone.

Immediate Consequences

If such a scenario were to occur, numerous dire consequences would immediately follow:

Kinslaying: Engaging in kinslaying represents the greatest sin in Tolkien's world. This act would stain Elrond's legacy and that of the Elves. Strengthening of Sauron: If Isildur were to be destroyed, Sauron would rise, potentially with even more power due to the Ring being destroyed within the volcano. Break in the Line of Kings: While Isildur had a son who could carry on the line, the concept of the Ring being destroyed in the volcano ensures the continuance of the kingship. Tensions Between Men and Elves: The act of kinslaying would likely create an unprecedented rift between the races of Men and Elves, leading to further conflicts and distrust. Humanity's War Mentality: The hypothetical world would see Men, known for their war-like nature, torn apart in an unprecedented confrontation with the Elves. This conflict could lead to the near-extinction of Men.

Long-Term Consequences

The ripple effects of this hypothetical scenario would be profound and far-reaching:

Elves Leaving Middle-earth: In reaction to the inhumane behavior displayed by Men, the Elves might choose to leave Middle-earth, leading to a drastic decrease in the population of the region. Prosperous Dwarf Kingdoms: With Men and Elves gone, it is possible that the Dwarf kingdoms might thrive without the fear of a unified Men-Elves-Sauron alliance. Surviving Threats: Despite the loss of Men and Elves, other threats such as Balrogs, Trolls, and Orcs would still exist, leading to a different balance of power.

While this scenario is entirely hypothetical, it provides a fascinating insight into the depths of Tolkien's world, where every action has significant consequences. The potential for the Ring's destruction in the volcano not only ensures the safety of Middle-earth but also maintains the delicate balance of power among its inhabitants.