The Impact of Choosing a House on the Westeros Story: Tyrells and Arryns in A Song of Ice and Fire

In the complex and intricate narrative of George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series, the houses of Westeros hold significant power. If you were to choose, which house would you join, and how would your membership impact the story's progression? Let's explore two intriguing possibilities:

Option 1: House Tyrell

I would undoubtedly choose to be a part of House Tyrell, specifically aligning with my grandmother Olenna Tyrell, the Queen of Thorns. Olenna's cunning and strategic mind would be invaluable in navigating the power struggles of King's Landing. I would be groomed to serve as Lord of Highgarden, a position respected and revered far more than Olenna’s son Mace’s.

Our path would diverge from the main storyline when Olenna decided to flee from King’s Landing. My family and I would escape the wildfire, which decimated the rest of our kin. This act would preserve our lineage's hopes and ensure Highgarden continued to be a stronghold against the Lannister threat.

As we rallied to defend Highgarden from Lord Tywin Lannister's relentless army, I would witness a critical turning point in the war. With me at the helm, Jaime Lannister would face a crushing defeat, potentially altering the balance of power in Westeros.

Our alliance with Daenerys Targaryen would be tested as events unfold. Until it became clear that Daenerys could no longer serve as our best hope for securing Highgarden, we would remain loyal to her. However, once the tide turned, my family and I would join Dany's final meeting, emphasizing the importance of reason over rash decisions that could lead to chaos.

Option 2: House Arryn

Alternatively, I would choose to be a part of House Arryn, specifically as the heir to the mountain and vale. This house's reputation for honor and chivalry, along with their unique position in the mountains, would provide a different but equally compelling trajectory.

As a cadet branch or a younger brother of one of the Kings of the Mountain and Vale, I would rule over my own keep, a position that would allow me to enjoy the secluded and peaceful lifestyle unique to the Vale. The Arryns' staunch adherence to the Andal Faith of the Seven would also be reflected in my character, making me a reserved and contemplative ruler.

Alternatively, I could have been the eldest son of Jaeherys II and married to my sister, potentially averting the horrors of Robert's Rebellion and the subsequent destruction of much of Westeros. By standing against Aerys II Targaryen, I would prevent the loss of thousands of lives and ensure a more stable future for the realm.

Conclusion

Both options present unique challenges and opportunities. Choosing House Tyrell would involve navigating the treacherous waters of King's Landing and the intense political and military conflicts. On the other hand, choosing House Arryn would allow for a more noble and honorable path, emphasizing the importance of land, honor, and a peaceful existence.

No matter the choice, each house would play a crucial role in shaping the future of Westeros. The decisions made by these houses would continue to impact the series, making the choices of House Tyrell and House Arryn particularly compelling.