The Fate of Anakin Skywalker: Would Vader Have Defeated Sidious in His Prime?

Recent Star Wars comics have depicted a weakened Darth Sidious struggling to control Darth Vader. This raises an intriguing question: would a more powerful and unshackled Vader be able to overcome the Emperor in a confrontation? Drawing from sources such as comics and the prequels, we explore the dynamics between Anakin Skywalker and his master, offering a thorough analysis.

Vader and Sidious: A Power Struggle

Despite Vader’s increased strength during his prime, his allegiance to Sidious remains unshaken. In Star Wars lore, Palpatine claims, “I will be more powerful than either of us.” This statement highlights the Emperor's belief in his ascendency over the once-powerful Jedi, indicating that Vader would never truly achieve his full potential while serving Sidious. Instead, Vader is seen as a tool, a weapon crafted by the Emperor’s will and force in the dark side.

Vader's Mindset and Behavior

The strength of Vader during his prime would depend heavily on his mindset. Angered, Vader would likely focus on killing rather than simply obeying his master. In such a state, he may even dare to challenge Sidious's authority, leading to a confrontation that could determine their ultimate fate. However, even in these heightened states, Vader ultimately submission to Sidious.

The Emperor's Psychological Mastery

Sidious’s mastery of the dark side and his manipulation skills are unparalleled. His ability to undermine Vader's confidence is a crucial factor in maintaining his control. In numerous scenarios, including his torture of Vader, Sidious consistently and effectively weakened his opponent's resolve. This psychological hold over Vader suggests that, even in his prime, he would submit to the Emperor's demands.

Conclusion: Realities of Torture and Submission

Considering the events depicted in Star Wars comics and the enduring influence of Sidious’s mastery, it is highly unlikely that a more powerful Vader would decisively defeat Sidious. Emperor Palpatine’s torture methods were designed to strip away Vader’s will, and during his prime, Vader would continue to submit to his tormentor. Even if Sidious were weakened, his psychological and force prowess would ensure that Vader would not challenge him.

The power dynamics between Vader and Sidious are complex, rooted in both their individual strengths and the dark side's mastery. While Vader’s unchained potential and rage might initially defy Sidious, ultimately, his allegiance to the Emperor would prevail. In essence, even in his prime, Vader would likely submit to Palpatine's will.