The Art of Writing: What Books Should You Not Attempt to Write?

Every writer dreams of sharing their voice, creativity, and knowledge with the world. However, there are certain genres and topics that may not be the best fit for everyone. In this article, we will explore why you should be cautious about some book types and what unique challenges writers face when tackling certain genres, such as comedy and fan fiction.

Why You Shouldn't Write a Book You Are Incompetent to Write

One of the first lessons many writers learn is to stick to what they know. For instance, don't write a book on a subject you are not competent in. Attempting to write a biology textbook without the necessary expertise can not only lead to errors but also a loss of credibility and reader trust. It's essential to choose a genre and topic that align with your knowledge and experience.

Comedy: The Hardest Genre to Tackle

Perhaps the most challenging genre to write is comedy. While humor is universal, the art of crafting and mastering comedic writing is unique and can be extremely difficult. Here are some reasons why writing comedy is a daunting task:

1. Natural Humor Is Hard to Achieve

Unlike other forms of writing, you can't just be born naturally funny. Writing comedy requires specific skills and a deep understanding of human behavior, irony, and satire. Even watching performances or performances does not guarantee that you will successfully replicate it.

2. Originality and Innovation

Watching a football player might enhance your skills on the field, but the same is not true for comedy. Watching comedians perform might inspire you but can often lead to imitation, which does not always translate well. If you try to mimic the jokes or styles of other comedians, your work may lack originality and feel insincere.

3. Avoiding Offense

In a highly sensitive and critical era, any perceived offensive content can lead to backlash. Even the smallest joke or word choice can be misconstrued and cause a hostile reaction from readers or critics. It's crucial to be sensitive to the audience and avoid topics that may trigger negative feelings.

4. Audience Perception

When a comedy routine fails, the audience's laughter changes. The crowd will no longer laugh with you as your joke transitions into a monologue aimed at you. This is one of the clearest signs that a comedy piece is not working. This can be an exhausting and disheartening experience, but it is also a crucial learning opportunity for aspiring comedians.

In conclusion, while writing comedy can be immensely rewarding, it is not for everyone. If you don't have the necessary skills, it might be best to avoid this genre and focus on other areas where you can shine. On the other hand, if you are passionate about trying it, don't let fear hold you back.

Why Should You Avoid Fan Fiction?

Another book type to avoid is fan fiction. While it may be satisfying to explore the world you love, fan fiction often lacks the genuine appeal that readers are looking for. Here are some reasons why:

1. Lack of Originality

Fan fiction is typically a re-imagining of existing characters and storylines. While this can be a fun exercise, it often fails to stand out in a crowded market. Readers generally seek unique, innovative stories rather than rehashed versions of beloved characters.

2. Limited Audience

While there are passionate fans of fan fiction, the niche audience can be quite small. Unless you are writing within a very specific and dedicated fanbase, your work may not gain the attention you desire. The broader public tends to look for original content that offers something new and exciting.

3. Shelf-Life and Relevance

Unlike original works, fan fiction tends to have a shorter shelf-life. As the original stories and characters evolve, so do the reader expectations. Maintaining relevance and interest over time can be challenging, making it harder to build a lasting audience.

While fan fiction can be a great pastime for those deeply invested in a specific universe, it may not be the best choice for those looking to establish a broader readership and a lasting literary presence.

In summary, just as you wouldn't try to write about a subject you are not knowledgeable in, it is important to recognize the challenges of writing comedy and fan fiction. By understanding these limitations, writers can focus on genres and topics that align with their skills and passions, ultimately leading to more fulfilling and successful writing careers.