Understanding the Complexity of Renly's Title

When considering Renly Baratheon's potential title as Lord of Summerhall, it's crucial to understand the historical and political context of the region. Renly lacks substantial support in the Stormlands, with powerful houses such as the Swanns and Dondarrions being absent. Even neutral houses like the Selmys might initially hesitate. This imbalance in support sets the stage for a complex political landscape in the aftermath of any power shifts.

The Influences and Power Dynamics

As the proposed Lord of Summerhall, Renly would find himself governing an area previously under Targaryen rule. The status of fealty to the crown versus Storm’s End remains ambiguous, which could lead to either direct loyalty to Robert, or to Storm’s End under Joffrey's control. The outcome would likely be decided based on the prevailing power dynamics and strategic alliances.

Renly's position would be inherently weaker compared to his influential and wealthy brothers. He would have the bloodline, but limited power and wealth. It is likely that Renly would find himself in a courtly role, acting as the king's brother, possibly even joining the Small Council. The House Tyrells may view Renly as a potential ally and use him to gain leverage within the court.

A significant factor in Renly's stance would be his own motivations and alignment with existing factions. If he remains true to his title of King's Hand, he is unlikely to readily join the cause of Stannis, given his loyalty to Robert. However, Renly's significant military forces could make him a sought-after ally by various factions during the inevitable civil war, including the potential broker in negotiations such as the Joffrey to Marg betrothal. Storm's End could be one of his potential rewards for such services.

The State and Rebuilding of Summerhall

Summerhall, a former Targaryen royal domain and a place where Rhaegar was known to stay, fell into ruins after Aegon V's failed attempt to hatch dragons. While it is not at the level of Harrenhal, which still has people living and claiming the title, parts of Summerhall still stand.

If Robert chose to give Renly the land, it is reasonable to assume he would invest in rebuilding the manor or mansion. This would align with Robert's strategy to secure his position through the restoration of strategic locations. Summerhall, despite not being a full castle, has served as a vacation home and would benefit from restoration. This strategic move would both demonstrate Robert's intentions and provide Renly with a valuable base of operations.

Likewise, rebuilding Summerhall would not just be about creating an empty title but would offer practical benefits. It would serve as a base for soldiers and administration, facilitating the collection of tax revenue. The reconstruction efforts would likely be seen as an investment in stability and order, aligning with the broader interests of the realm.

To conclude, the title of Lord of Summerhall would not be an empty one but would come with its own set of responsibilities and benefits. With the right political maneuvering and strategic investment, Renly could turn Summerhall into a functional and influential stronghold.