Ridiculous Aspects of the 1950 Disney Cinderella Movie Revisited

Over the years, the 1950 Disney adaptation of Cinderella has captivated audiences with its enchanting tale and beloved characters. However, a closer look at the film reveals a few aspects that, upon closer inspection, seem quite ridiculous. This article explores the most notable and comical elements of the movie, providing a fresh perspective on a timeless classic.

Typical Ridiculousness: Talking Mice and Fairy Godmother

Many would point to the talking mice, the Fairy Godmother's magic, and the overall fantastical elements of the story as the primary sources of ridicule. These tropes, after all, are expected in a Disney movie, and are integral to the plot. However, there's a more specific and rather amusing aspect that stands out as particularly absurd. And it's not something like the talking mice, but rather an unusual architectural detail: the clock tower that rings at midnight.

The Midway Spectacle: The Clock Tower's Absurdity

The clock tower in the 1950 Disney Cinderella film is a prime example of incredulous design. This tower, with its relentless and loud chimes at midnight, turns out to be the most ridiculous part of the entire movie. Think of it like a real-life Big Ben disease that plagues the palace grounds. Here's why it's so hard to believe:

Non-Stop Ticking: The clock’s chimes ring every hour, day and night. If true, this would mean the noise would never cease, making it impossible for anyone to sleep. Ultrasound Effects: The sound is described as so deafening that it rattles windows and teeth. This intrusive noise would make holding a conversation utterly impossible. How many times have you tried to have a conversation in a noisy environment? It’s a challenge. Practical Inconsistencies: In a grand palace setting, where silence and luxury are expected, such a loud and constant noise is unrealistic. Imagine trying to hold a private meeting in the throne room, where the clock's chimes are echoing through the halls. Chaos!

The clock tower's persistent ringing announces the end of the magical transformation and signals that Cinderella must leave. What rational person would build such a device in their palace? Sure, the movie is magical, but this aspect strains credulity. Who in their right mind would design a home with a feature that constantly disrupts the peace and privacy of the residents?

Wishful Thinking and Practicality

Cinderella's magical fairy godmother offers a wide range of gifts, from wealth to her dream dress for the ball. The movie is filled with other magical and whimsical elements. However, one can't help but wonder why Cinderella didn't ask for something more substantial, like a new home or a substantial sum of money. Granting a luxurious gown and carriage to a poor girl is benevolent, but a little foresight would have been helpful.

Problems with Cinderella's Wishes

If a magical being grants you a wish, what would you wish for? Most people might ask for something practical, like wealth to start a new life, or durable items that could significantly improve their circumstances. Wealth would not only provide a luxurious gown and carriage but also resources that would last beyond midnight. Asking for money would ensure that she could buy a house, live comfortably, and maybe even have some savings. These would be tangible assets that wouldn't evaporate at midnight.

Conclusion: Balancing Fantasy and Reality

The 1950 Disney Cinderella serves as an excellent example of blending fantasy with realistic nuances. While our focus here was on the absurdly noisy clock tower and Cinderella’s less-than-strategic wishes, it’s important to remember that these elements enhance the overall charm and entertainment value of the movie. The movie's ability to maintain a balance between whimsical magic and realistic problem-solving makes it a timeless classic that has stood the test of time. Despite the amusingly ridiculous aspects, the movie remains a cherished piece of cinematic art.