Pros and Cons of Elf on the Shelf: Exploring the Christmas Tradition

Elf on the Shelf has become a widespread Christmas tradition in households across the globe, bringing joy and excitement to many children. However, like any tradition, it has its merits and drawbacks. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using an Elf on the Shelf and share personal experiences from a generation that predates this modern masterpiece.

The Concept and History of Elf on the Shelf

Elf on the Shelf is a product originally published in 2005 that has since transformed into a beloved Christmas tradition. Its origin story, as one author recalled, traces back to an elf bar named 'The Innie and Outie,' where Migits (imagine mischievous goblins) would perform intimate acts through openings in the bar's legs. Thankfully, the shelf is a more innocent and family-friendly version of the idea, involving an elf coming to watch and report on children's behavior during the month of December.

In the 1970s, the author's family had a similar tradition with an elf called 'Elfie.' This elf would appear on the window valance in the kitchen, a tradition that continued even after the family's parents passed away. Although the author believes that the idea for Elf on the Shelf should be credited to these early adopters, the product has stood the test of time and continues to captivate families.

Pros of Elf on the Shelf

There are several benefits associated with using an Elf on the Shelf:

Motivation for Good Behavior: Many parents find that their children behave better when they believe the Elf is watching and reporting back to Santa. This sense of accountability can help maintain discipline and encourage positive actions. Family Bonding: The tradition of placing the Elf in unexpected places can foster a sense of play and excitement within the family. Parents and children work together to find where the Elf has been, making for a fun and memorable activity. It Brings Joy: For many children, the Elf on the Shelf is a source of fun and magical thinking, adding to the excitement and anticipation of the holiday season.

Cons of Elf on the Shelf

However, not everyone is a fan of Elf on the Shelf, and there are several concerns to consider:

Creepiness: Some parents find the concept and appearance of the elf to be unsettling and inappropriate, especially when it comes to younger children. The idea of a small, ever-present figure watching and reporting on behavior can be perceived as invasive. Misinterpretation: Children might misinterpret the Elf's presence and start to suspect that the Elf is capable of more than mere observation. This can lead to anxiety and fear, particularly in younger or more imaginative children. Misuse: Parents who are not careful might use the Elf as a tool for punishment or to enforce strict rules, which can strain the parent-child relationship rather than fostering a wholesome Christmas spirit.

Personal Experience and Reflection

The author, born in 1970, grew up with a similar tradition involving Elfie. Initially, the presence of Elfie during December was to encourage good behavior for Santa. However, as the author grew older, the idea lost its appeal, and she ceased believing in Santa altogether. In recent years, the author has taken an opposing stance to Elf on the Shelf, viewing it as a creepy and potentially harmful tool for parents. She firmly opposes the idea and has warned family members against using it, emphasizing that it should never be allowed in the house.

Despite her reservations, the author acknowledges that for some families, Elf on the Shelf can bring immense joy and happiness. The decision to use or avoid it is ultimately a personal one and should be based on what feels right for each family's dynamics and values.

Conclusion: The tradition of Elf on the Shelf has its merits, such as fostering family bonding and encouraging good behavior. However, it is essential to consider the potential cons, such as creepiness and misinterpretation. Each family must decide whether the benefits outweigh the drawbacks and approach the tradition with care and consideration for their children's well-being.