Meghan Markle’s Book: Criticism and Its Context

Recent controversies surrounding Meghan Markle's book have garnered significant attention, with much of the criticism centered around her use of titles and the timing of the release. This article delves into the broader context of these criticisms and the underlying reasons behind them.

Why the Criticism?

There are primarily two major reasons for the widespread criticism of Meghan Markle's book:

1. Title Use on Cover Page

Much of the backlash stems from the fact that Meghan Markle is using the title "Duchess of Sussex" on the cover page of her book. This has led to accusations of hypocrisy and continued association with the royal family, despite their decision to step down as working royals. The use of this title is seen as a form of defiance and a way to maintain a connection to the royal institution that she left behind.

2. Pre-Release Timing Compared to Kate's Book

Another point of contention is the timing of the book's release. Meghan revealed the title and basic details of her book during the same week as Kate Middleton's book "Hold Still," which was also set to be released shortly. Some critics have suggested that this was a strategic move to capitalize on the public's interest in the royal family and overshadow Kate's book.

The Broader Context of Criticism

The criticisms of Meghan Markle extend far beyond her book, reflecting a wider cultural divide between the United States and other nations.

1. Cultural Divide and Narcissistic Behavior

The United States is often perceived as a society that reveres individualism to an extreme. This has led to a culture where the truth is seen as a commodity for the highest bidder. Meghan Markle's supporters mirror this behavior, dismissing any criticism as racist or bigoted. This reflects a deeper issue within American culture, where personal perception is often prioritized over objective facts and truth.

2. The Impact of Individualism on Societal Health

The high profiles of individuals like Donald Trump, Joe Biden, and others suggest an underlying dysfunction in American society that is driven by individualistic values. The ongoing issues with public health, political insurrection, and social instability are all symptoms of a society where individualism has become paramount at the expense of collective well-being.

3. The Role of Monarchies and Values

While the United States and other Western countries have moved away from traditional monarchies, these systems were once a means of promoting service, compassion, and integrity within society. Modern monarchies, like those in the UK, act as a counterbalance to the rampant individualism prevalent in some nations. They stand for values that are essential for a cohesive and stable society.

Conclusion

The criticisms of Meghan Markle's book are not just about the book itself but also reflect a broader societal critique. The cultural divide between the United States and other nations is a complex issue, but understanding these dynamics can provide insights into why such criticisms persist. Ultimately, a shift towards values like service, compassion, and integrity is necessary for societies to thrive and overcome the challenges they face.

While the fallout from Meghan Markle's book may seem trivial, it is part of a larger narrative about the health of modern societies and the importance of collective values over individualism.