Is the Infernal Devices Series Worth Reading Over Mortal Instruments?

When it comes to the magical world created by Cassandra Clare, fans often find themselves questioning which series is superior. Two of Clare's most popular series, Mortal Instruments and Dark Artifices, have captivated young adult readers with their intricate plotlines, richly developed characters, and stunning world-building. But what about the Infernal Devices series? Is it worth exploring over the Mortal Instruments series?

Overview of the Series

The Dark Artifices series, like its predecessor the Mortal Instruments series, follows the fantastical journey of young protagonists through a world ripe with magic, mystery, and danger. While the two series share some common themes and elements, they differ in several key aspects that set them apart. The Infernal Devices series, released in 2015, is part of the same universe as the Mortal Instruments but is set in a different time period, introduced by the City of Glass prequel.

Comparing the Series

Romance and Fantasy Blend

One of the aspects that sets Mortal Instruments apart is its perfect blend of romance and fantasy. Critics and readers alike often praise Series franchise’s ability to balance these elements without overwhelming the story. Specifically, Infernal Devices also features robust romantic arcs, but some argue that the series leans slightly more towards fantasy at the cost of reduced romance. In Mortal Instruments, the romantic subplots are integrated seamlessly with the main storyline, ensuring that no single plotline overshadows the other.

Character Development

Character development is a fundamental aspect of any successful YA series, and both Mortal Instruments and Infernal Devices excel in this area. The Mortal Instruments series is often lauded for its well-rounded characters, each with their unique strengths and vulnerabilities. In contrast, the Infernal Devices series introduces a new cast of characters, some of whom may benefit from a more in-depth exploration to fully develop their arcs. The Mortal Instruments series, with its established franchises, allows for a more nuanced understanding of the characters' backgrounds and motivations.

Setting and World-Building

The Mortal Instruments series is notable for its rich and detailed world-building. The story unfolds in a world where supernatural beings like Downworlders and Shadowhunters coexist alongside humans. The Infernal Devices series, while maintaining the same universe, sets the stage in a different time period, giving readers a fresh perspective. However, some readers argue that the Mortal Instruments series provides a more complex and immersive setting due to its longer run and the time to explore various aspects of the world.

Why Choose Mortal Instruments?

For those who prefer a deeper, more intricate storyline with a harmonious blend of romance and fantasy, the Mortal Instruments series might be the better choice. The series offers a comprehensive exploration of its characters and world, providing a richer and more engaging reading experience. Additionally, the Mortal Instruments series has a broader readership and critical acclaim, making it a more reliable starting point for new readers.

Why Consider Infernal Devices?

On the other hand, those who are drawn to fresh perspectives and a different time in the Mortal Instruments universe might find the Infernal Devices series more appealing. The series offers a new set of characters and a fresh take on the same magical world, which can be exciting for fans looking for a new angle.

Conclusion

The choice between the Mortal Instruments and Infernal Devices series largely depends on personal preference. Both series offer unique experiences, with different strengths in terms of character development, world-building, and the integration of romance and fantasy. Whether you want to explore the well-established characters and richly detailed world of the Mortal Instruments series or dive into a fresh perspective through the Infernal Devices series, both offer compelling stories that will keep you engaged.

By understanding the unique features and strengths of both series, you can choose the one that best fits your reading interests and preferences. So, why not explore both and decide for yourself which series leaves an indelible mark on your bookshelf?

Keywords: Infernal Devices, Mortal Instruments, Cassandra Clare