Is Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children Suitable for a PG Rating?

Should the critically acclaimed and visually stunning film, Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children, be edited from a PG-13 movie to a PG movie to ensure that all kids can see it?

Current Rating: PG-13

The current rating of Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children is PG-13, which means it may be suitable for children ten years of age and older. However, parental guidance is recommended due to scary themes, and some violence and horror elements. This rating is based on the movie's inclusion of intense thematic material, horror, and some sexual content.

Arguments for Keeping PG-13 Rating

Content Appropriateness: Despite its dark segments, Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children maintains a relatively clean storyline, without controversial themes or mature content that might be inappropriate for younger audiences. The movie focuses on themes of friendship, bravery, and family, with a strong moral message. These qualities are more aligned with a PG rating.

Intended Audience: The film is targeted towards an older middle school and early high school audience who can appreciate its magical realism and the complex emotional journey of its characters. By keeping a PG-13 rating, it effectively caters to this niche audience who are ready to engage with some darker content while still enjoying the overall narrative.

Arguments for Lowering to PG Rating

Parental Guidance: Parents might be concerned about the horror elements and intense thematic material that could have psychological impacts on impressionable minds. A PG rating ensures these warning signs are clear to parents, allowing them to make informed decisions about what their children should watch.

Accessibility: Allowing the film to reach a wider audience could significantly benefit its diverse fan base, particularly younger children who might be too young for a PG-13 movie but old enough to enjoy the fantasy elements and thrilling story. This change could widen the film's appeal and reach more families.

Consistent Rating System Across Media

Industry Standards: The rating system is designed to be consistent across all forms of media. Movies, television shows, and video games all have their rating explanations, which helps parents make decisions. Keeping Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children at a PG-13 could create confusion and inconsistency if its rating were lowered given its target audience.

Marketing and Audience Expectations: The marketing and promotion surrounding Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children explicitly focus on the darker aspects and the need for appropriate viewing. A PG rating could mislead audiences or damage the movie's credibility within its specific fan base.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the decision to change the rating from PG-13 to PG is a complex one. While parental guidance is always recommended, the current PG-13 rating strikes a balance between ensuring the movie reaches its intended audience while still providing a caution against potentially scary and intense content. Whether the rating should change depends on the film's continued execution of its storytelling and the audience's expectations moving forward. Until there's an overwhelming case for a change, maintaining the PG-13 rating appears to be the best approach.

Watch Alpha Curation

Watch Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children on IMDb