Introduction

The Harry Potter universe offers numerous alternate scenarios that could drastically change the course of events. One such fascinating scenario involves Voldemort's decision to spare Lily Potter, killing Harry instead. This article explores the immediate and long-term outcomes of such an alternate timeline, focusing on Lily's reactions and the broader implications for the wizarding world.

Immediate Consequences

Harry's Death

Predictively, if Voldemort had killed Harry, the prophecy stating Lily Potter's death would have been fulfilled. This prediction would have been catastrophic for the wizarding world. Voldemort's victory would have been inevitable, leading to a dark and oppressive regime with dire consequences for all.Potter fans and loyalists would mourn the loss of a symbol of hope and resistance, while those who supported Voldemort would celebrate an apparent victory.

Lily's Reaction

The loss of her son Lily Potter would have been an unbearable blow. Her grief would be profound, driving her to protect her remaining family and create a new purpose in life. The prophecy would no longer bind her, but her instincts as a mother would ensure she would not rest until Harry was avenged. Lily’s mourning would be intense, and her desire for revenge would likely fuel her to seek out allies and fight against the dark forces.

Long-Term Outcomes

Lily’s Path

After the tragic loss of Harry, Lily might transform into a formidable force against Voldemort. Fueled by her deep anger and a relentless drive for vengeance, she might seek out allies among the remaining members of the Order of the Phoenix and other anti-Voldemort factions. Her grief could become a powerful and motivating factor, potentially leading her to become a leader in the fight against dark magic.

Confrontation with Wormtail

If Lily discovered that Peter Pettigrew (Wormtail) had betrayed her family, her grief and rage would intensify. This betrayal would provide her with a reason to confront Wormtail. Depending on her emotional state, she might confront him in a moment of fury or seek justice by turning him over to the authorities. Given her character, she would likely struggle with the morality of killing but the depth of her loss could push her towards a more ruthless path.

Impact on the Wizarding World

Lily's actions could inspire others to rise against Voldemort, potentially leading to a different resistance movement. If she successfully rallied others, it could spark a new war against the dark forces, potentially leading to an earlier downfall of Voldemort albeit at significant personal cost. The impact would be far-reaching, with many leaders and followers inspired by her example.

Alternate Character Development

Lily as a Dark Avenger

If Lily embraced her grief and anger, she might adopt a darker persona, becoming a figure feared by Death Eaters. This transformation could lead to her employing methods she previously would have deemed unacceptable, as she seeks to protect her family and the remaining population from Voldemort's regime.

Redemption Arc

Alternatively, if Lily chose to honor Harry’s memory by fighting for good, her journey could become one of redemption. Her focus would be on protecting others, ensuring that no one else suffers the fate of her son. This path would be more aligned with her initial character but would still involve a significant inner struggle as she seeks redemption for her lost love.

Conclusion

In this alternate scenario, Lily’s choices would shape not only her own fate but also the fate of the wizarding world. The loss of Harry would create a ripple effect that would alter alliances, motivations, and the overall trajectory of the fight against Voldemort. Ultimately, her response to the tragedy could define her legacy in the wizarding world, whether as a vengeful avenger or a beacon of hope.