The Alternate History of Westeros: If Tywin Lannister Were Robert Baratheon's Hand

Imagine a different Westeros if Robert Baratheon, after the chaotic period of Roberts Rebellion, had chosen Tywin Lannister over Jon Arryn as his Hand of the King. This significant decision would have wrought fundamental changes to the political, social, and economic fabric of the realm. In this alternate history, we explore the potential outcomes of such a choice.

Stronger Central Authority

Unlike Jon Arryn, who was known for his conciliatory approach, Tywin Lannister was a master of administrative discipline and ruthlessness. His appointment as Hand of the King would likely have resulted in a more resilient central authority.

From the start, Tywin would have implemented stringent measures to maintain order and consolidate power. This might have included purging political enemies, ensuring the loyalty of key nobles, and implementing policies to control the regions.

Tension with the Starks

Jon Arryn maintained a good relationship with House Stark, having mentored the Starks and Eddard Stark in particular. However, Tywin had a long-standing rivalry with House Stark, dating back to the time of Aerys II Targaryen. His appointment as Hand would have soured relations with the North severely, potentially leading to an earlier and more intense conflict between the Iron Throne and the Stark family.

Handling of the Targaryens

When it came to the remnants of House Targaryen, Tywin's approach would likely have been much more aggressive. He might have sought to eliminate perceived threats to Robert's rule, using force to quell any potential uprisings from loyalists to the defunct Targaryen dynasty.

While this strategy could have expedited the end of any Targaryen resurgence, it could also have led to backlash from loyalists, thereby sowing further discord in the realm.

Manipulation of Alliances

Known for his strategic acumen, Tywin would have attempted to forge alliances to support his rule. He might have sought to strengthen ties with House Martell or House Tyrell, altering the balance of power and preventing potential conflicts.

Economic Policies

Under Tywin's leadership, the kingdom's economic stability would have been a priority. However, his methods might have involved heavy taxation, which could have led to unrest among the peasantry and the broader populace.

Impact on the Lannisters’ Power

With Tywin firmly in control of the Hand of the King, the Lannisters' power would have been solidified. This could have accelerated the rivalry with the Baratheons, setting the stage for internal conflicts.

Legacy of Robert’s Reign

Robert's reign, characterized by a relaxed and hedonistic lifestyle, might have stabilized under Tywin's guidance. However, Tywin's ruthless nature could have intensified Robert's paranoia and recklessness, leading to a form of tyranny that was different but equally dangerous.

The realm would have experienced a markedly different trajectory, with potential for earlier conflicts and shifts in alliances that could extend well into the future.

Conclusion

In the end, the appointment of Tywin Lannister as Hand of the King would have led to a more authoritarian and strategically calculated rule. While this could bring about short-term stability and power consolidation, it would also set the stage for increased conflict, particularly with the North and other powerful houses. The potential ramifications of such a choice could echo far into the future, shaping the history of Westeros in unforeseen ways.