The Intersection of Discovery Writing and Plotting in Novels

When discussing the writing process, a common distinction is made between discovery writers and plotter writers. Discovery writers, also known as pantsers, prefer to let their stories unfold organically through the writing process. On the other hand, plotter writers extensively outline their stories before ever putting pen to paper. However, many leading authors, like Stephen King and J.K. Rowling, fit into the discovery category, challenging the notion that plotting and discovery cannot coexist.

Stephen King and J.K. Rowling’s Unorthodox Approach

Stephen King, renowned for his popular horror series, famously claims he doesn’t outline his novels. Similarly, J.K. Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter books, is known to prioritize the discovery method. While it’s impossible to know the exact number of novels that were written through discovery rather than outlined, it is evident that many prominent authors adopt this style, often producing works of high quality.

Examples of Pantsing in Established Literature

Isaac Asimov, despite his reputation as a meticulous planner, was often found "pantsing" his stories. According to published accounts, Asimov actively disliked the act of plotting. He would develop his stories through the writing process, allowing his intuition and creativity to guide his decisions. Another example can be found in Agatha Christie’s writing. Some of her works were reportedly discovered rather than plotted. Christie devised clues and plot twists as she wrote, often making her final decisions regarding the ultimate murderer toward the end of the story.

The Intricacies of Revision in Discovery Writing

Despite the organic nature of discovery writing, the final product often undergoes significant revisions. These revisions help to tighten up loose ends and ensure the story flows logically and cohesively. For intuitive writers, such as the author of this piece, the discovery method often works in tandem with traditional outlining. A well-developed outline serves as a roadmap, guiding the writing process, but it is never set in stone. A sudden inspiration can lead to significant plot changes, and such adaptability is essential in the pursuit of a compelling narrative.

Blending Discovery and Plotting Techniques

The line between discovery writing and plotting can be blurred. In the early stages of a writer's career, they might rely more heavily on outlines, especially for short stories. As they gain confidence, they might reduce the level of planning, opting for a more intuitive approach. This flexibility allows writers to harness the benefits of both methods. Personal growth and writing experience can influence the writer’s preference between discovery and plotting, ultimately shaping their unique process.

For instance, short stories written exclusively by outlining can be tightly plotted, demonstrating the potential for detailed planning. However, novels may require a more fluid approach, allowing for the emergence of unexpected plot twists. A well-crafted outline can reduce the uncertainty of the writing process, but it should be seen as a flexible tool rather than a strict set of rules.

While the discovery method can produce outstanding literature, it is essential to recognize that a well-plotted outline can also enhance a story. The experience and intuition of the author play crucial roles in both methods, guiding the narrative and making it compelling for readers.

Conclusion

The distinction between discovery writers and plotter writers is not as rigid as it might seem. Many renowned authors, like Stephen King and J.K. Rowling, have successfully blended both approaches to produce award-winning novels. The discovery method can be a powerful tool for organic storytelling and character development, while a detailed outline can ensure a tightly structured and coherent narrative. Both methods, when used effectively, contribute to the richness and depth of the literary world.