Harry Potter or A Song of Ice and Fire: Which One Should You Read First?

When it comes to choosing between A Song of Ice and Fire and Harry Potter, the decision can be a daunting one, especially if you're not a native English speaker. You might be considering which series to start with given that you've watched neither of their film or television adaptations. This article aims to guide you based on your unique situation and reading preferences.

Why Harry Potter Is the Better Starting Point

If you are not a native English speaker, Harry Potter will be a comparatively easier read. The vocabulary is simpler, making it more accessible for non-native speakers. Additionally, the film and television adaptations of Harry Potter are known for leaving out some of the story's richness, such as dialogues, scenes, and complex character relationships, which you'll experience through the books.

Having read both series multiple times, I can confidently say that Harry Potter is a must-read. Not only are the books engaging and fun to read, but they also offer valuable life lessons. For first-time readers, the journey can feel transformative, leading to endless "what if" scenarios and discussions with fellow fans. If you read Harry Potter for the first time as a child, you can revisit them now and discover new layers and meanings in the stories.

Advantages of Starting with Harry Potter

1. Accessibility: Harry Potter uses relatively simple language, making it easier to grasp the narrative and characters.

2. Engagement: The story is gripping and fun, drawing you in from the very beginning. You won't be able to put it down.

3. Character Development: Both the books and the universal themes resonate with readers of all ages, offering a range of experiences from lighthearted adventures to more complex, nuanced characters.

Why Consider A Song of Ice and Fire as Well

However, if you are comfortable with more complex English and enjoy darker, more adventurous fantasy, you might want to consider A Song of Ice and Fire. George R.R. Martin (GRRM) uses a more intricate and sophisticated language, which might take some getting used to. The series is known for its deep, multi-layered plot, numerous characters, and its harsh and often violent realities.

A Song of Ice and Fire is a massive undertaking, with multiple storylines and complex characters. Reading it can be challenging but incredibly rewarding. The series can be slower to follow, especially with so many plot twists and character arcs, but once you're able to grasp the intricate web of events, it can become deeply engrossing.

Striking the Right Balance

If you are new to fantasy and prefer a more straightforward entry into the genre, Harry Potter is undoubtedly the better choice. You can then move on to A Song of Ice and Fire once you feel more comfortable with the language and narrative complexity.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on your reading comfort level and the type of experience you're looking for. If simplicity and fun are top priorities, go with Harry Potter. If you're ready for a more complex and engaging fantasy adventure, A Song of Ice and Fire might be the way to go.

Conclusion

After considering both options, Harry Potter is the clear choice for a non-native English speaker. The accessible language, engaging narrative, and profound life lessons make it an excellent starting point. Don't hesitate; start reading Harry Potter today and prepare to embark on an unforgettable literary journey.

You should read Harry Potter first!

Start reading now and let us know your thoughts in the comments below!