Which Genre Do You Like Better: Historical Fiction or Historical Fantasy?

As a reader and writer, my preferences can vary depending on the moment. Each genre has its unique charm and storytelling opportunities. Let’s explore the nuances and benefits of both historical fiction and historical fantasy to help you decide which genre better suits your taste.

As a Reader

When it comes to reading, I appreciate both genres. While my preference might shift based on my mood or the requirements of the moment, one genre isn’t necessarily superior to the other. Historical fiction immerses me in a world grounded by real events and figures, making the narrative relatable and engaging. On the other hand, historical fantasy offers the thrill of alternative scenarios and creative interpretations, much like marital reality entertain me. For instance, a sighting of a historical king dying in a way that wouldn’t occur in real history can transport the narrative to a world of alternate history or fantasy. This flexibility allows for endless storytelling possibilities.

Personal Preferences

Given my limited exposure to fantasy literature, historical fiction naturally stands out to me. It might seem like a default preference, but that is partly due to my inherent appreciation for grounded and authentic narratives.

Author's Perspective

As a writer, I have a distinct preference for historical fantasy. The genre provides a canvas for creativity and invention, allowing me to bend reality and explore scenarios that may not have been possible in the historical context. For example, if I need a historical king to die under extraordinary circumstances, I can craft a storyline that works within the realm of fantasy. Suddenly, the narrative becomes an alternate history, opening up new avenues for narrative exploration. This flexibility is invaluable when crafting a compelling and immersive narrative.

Fiction vs. Fantasy

Fiction and fantasy share the same root, but they operate on different planes. Fiction, rooted in reality, offers a sense of relatability and authenticity. On the other hand, fantasy allows for imaginative expansion, pushing the boundaries of the known world. It’s a dance between the real and the imaginary, with each genre leveraging its strengths to captivate readers.

Recommended Authors and Works

When it comes to exemplifying these genres, Mary Stewart’s Merlin trilogy stands out as a prime example of historical fiction. The narrative is rich with historical context and character development, making it a compelling read. Conversely, Matthew Reilly’s The Tournament (2013) is an excellent example of historical fantasy. Set in 1543, the story follows Princess Elizabeth’s journey across Europe to watch a chess tournament. Despite the historical context, the author’s creative narrative and adventurous elements create a compelling and entertaining experience.

In summary, whether you are a casual reader or a writer, every reader appreciates both historical fiction and historical fantasy. Both genres have unique strengths and offer distinct reading experiences. Historical fiction provides a grounded, relatable narrative, while historical fantasy invites readers into a world of wonder and imagination. Each genre has its appeal, and it’s up to personal preference to determine which one resonates more.