Understanding the Risks and Ethics of Creating a Fake Family Tree on Ancestry

It is indeed possible to create a fake family tree on Ancestry, a widely used platform for genealogy and family history. Users can manually enter any information they choose, making it easy to create a phony family tree. However, this action can lead to significant risks and ethical dilemmas.

Creating a Fake Family Tree: The Pros and Cons

While the platform lacks stringent verification checks, allowing users to submit any information they desire, the consequences of creating a fake family tree can be severe. First and foremost, it can distort research findings and mislead others who may identify with the tree. Genealogical research should be based on confirmed records and verified data to ensure accuracy and reliability.

The Prevalence of Incorrect Family Trees

There are numerous incorrect family trees on Ancestry with so many continual errors that they can essentially be considered fake. Many users contribute erroneous or fictional information, leading to a misrepresentation of family histories. This can complicate research efforts and lead to misleading conclusions.

Genealogist’s Perspective

A genealogist’s experience with Ancestry demonstrates that many trees are unreliable. Unless the information can be confirmed through other sources, it is advisable to avoid relying solely on Ancestry data. While the platform can provide clues for further research, it is not infallible.

Motives and Consequences of Creating a Fake Tree

Some individuals might create a fake family tree with the intention of inventing rich relatives, hoping to deceive them into leaving an inheritance. Others might do so for personal amusement or to assert their identity. However, the consequences of such actions can be severe and damaging:

1. Diminishing Credibility: Creating fake data undermines the credibility of genealogical research. Scientists and researchers must maintain ethical standards to ensure the integrity of their work.

2. Responsible Behavior: Posting a fictitious tree is irresponsible, particularly when it is done to harm others or mislead the public. This behavior can harm other researchers, especially beginners who are more likely to believe the published data.

3. Potential Legal Implications: Submitting a phony DNA specimen to Ancestry is not only unethical but also potentially illegal. Ancestry, along with other DNA testing companies, may verify the information provided, and fabricating a family tree can lead to legal consequences, including being placed in a mental institution.

Alternatives to Creating a Fake Family Tree

Given the risks and ethical implications, why would someone choose to create a fake family tree when there are legitimate alternatives? Here are a few reasons:

1. Investigative Research: Conduct thorough research using various resources, such as public records, archives, and personal interviews, to build a credible family tree.

2. Professional Assistance: Utilize the services of experienced genealogists or consult with Ancestry's professional genealogy team for accurate and reliable information.

3. Personal Enjoyment: Engage in the fun and rewarding process of genealogy by learning about your family history through legitimate means.

Conclusion

While it is technically possible to create a fake family tree on Ancestry, it is not advisable due to the potential risks and ethical concerns. Ethical behavior and responsible research methods are crucial in the field of genealogy. If you value the integrity of your family research and the credibility of your work, it is best to avoid creating a fake family tree.