Eru's All-Powerful Lure: A Hallowed Discussion on Free Will and Character Development in Middle-earth

Understanding the complex interplay of power, free will, and character development in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth can be intellectually stimulating and engaging. One often-asked question delves into the seemingly paradoxical existence of powerful beings like Morgoth and Sauron within a world governed by an all-powerful entity, Eru. This discussion illuminates the intricate balance of control and autonomy in Tolkien's mythological framework, and how it serves both as a learning tool and a showcase of moral and ethical boundaries.

Unveiling the Essence of Middle-earth

Think of Middle-earth as a grand allegory or a parable, designed to impart profound lessons to both the Children of Eru and the reader. Eru, the Supreme Being in Tolkien's universe, shows the Children (both elves and men) the totality of their story through his omniscience before letting them immerse themselves in the narrative. This does not mean Eru abdicates control; rather, he chooses a more observational role to test the faith, resolve, and moral compass of his creations.

Eru's Role as a Creator and Observer

Eru's creation of Middle-earth is akin to Tolkien's own authorship. Just as Tolkien could not allow characters in The Lord of the Rings or The Silmarillion to act against his established narrative, Eru inherently constrains the actions of his creations. When Valar, the powerful spirits, defy Eru's will, the consequences are severe. For example, their actions in attempting to defeat Melkor led to the destruction of the Two Trees, highlighting how Eru's overarching plan is beyond their comprehension and control.

The Parable of Feanor and the Silmarils

The story of Feanor and the Silmarils illustrates a pivotal moment where the Valar's actions faced Eru's might. Feanor, in his rebellion and obsession to reclaim the Silmarils, acts in defiance of the Valar's authority. Despite the Valar's failure to replicate the Silmarils, they acknowledge that Feanor could only possess such knowledge through Eru's will. These events led to extensive destruction and conflict, further emphasizing Eru's ultimate control over events and the consequences of his creations' actions.

Gandalf's Philosophical Approach

Gandalf serves as a vital bridge between comprehension and faith. His deep understanding of Eru's plan and the greater good is evident in his actions and wisdom. However, his lack of knowledge regarding all aspects of Eru's plan allows him to live in hope and pursue his journey with faith. Gandalf’s role underscores the importance of trusting in a higher purpose, even when the full extent of that purpose remains unknown.

The Enigma of Dagor Dagorath

The concept of Dagor Dagorath, the final battle, creates a tantalizing ambiguity. This event, akin to the Christian concept of Armageddon, is both foretold and shrouded in mystery. It serves as a reminder not to lose faith and to cherish the moments of peace and hope in the current age. The ultimate fate of Melkor and the triumph of good over evil are guaranteed, but the specifics remain unresolved, leaving a sense of awe and mystery.

Conclusion

The question of why Eru allows the existence of Morgoth and Sauron is deeply rooted in the intricate balance of free will and divine oversight. It highlights the necessity of a creator's control over the narrative they have crafted, while also respecting the autonomy of their creations. This dynamic underscores the profound ethical and moral lessons embedded in Tolkien's Middle-earth, inviting readers to reflect on their own choices and the grand plans of those who observe from above.