Does Laurie Actually Love Amy or Is Their Marriage Simply a Substitute for Jo?

Little Women, the classic novel by Louisa May Alcott, has sparked numerous debates among its fans about the complex romantic relationship between Theodore "Laurie" Laurence and Amy March. A pivotal question often explored is whether Laurie truly loves Amy or if he married her solely to be part of the March family and because he couldn't get Jo.

Who Are Laurie and Amy?

Laurie is the wealthy and charming neighbor of the Marches, becoming a close friend and eventual love interest to Jo. When Jo rejects his proposal, Laurie goes to Europe, feeling that Jo is out of reach. Subsequently, he meets Amy and they form a deep connection, leading to their marriage. This quandary has puzzled many readers, questioning the nature of their relationship.

Evidence of Laurie's Genuine Emotion for Amy

Based on the evidence from the novel and various film adaptations, it can be argued that Laurie genuinely loves Amy. Below are several reasons to support this claim.

Shared Passions and Values

Firstly, Laurie and Amy share common interests and values that make their relationship strong and genuine. Both are passionate about art and culture Laurie plays the piano, flute, and has a refined taste for music, while Amy is an aspiring painter. They appreciate each other's artistic endeavors and enjoy visiting museums, galleries, and concerts together. Their similar sense of humor, adventurous spirits, ambitions, and kindness further solidify their connection.

Independently Formed Love

Secondly, Laurie's love for Amy is not based on a fixation or comparison to Jo. His feelings for Amy develop independently, free from Jo's influence. Laurie does not pursue Amy out of spite or an attempt to make Jo feel neglected. Instead, he respects Jo's decision and moves on to support Amy's unique aspirations. Amy, too, does not accept Laurie out of convenience or pity, respecting Jo's feelings and not trying to take her place. Laurie views Amy as a perfect partner rather than a consolation prize, and Amy sees him for who he is, embracing his strengths and weaknesses.

Positive and Harmonious Relationship

Lastly, Laurie and Amy's marriage is characterized by a balanced and supportive relationship. Laurie helps Amy overcome her vanity and becomes more humble and generous, while Amy encourages Laurie to be more disciplined and productive. Together, they create a harmonious environment where they listen, communicate, and compromise effectively.

In conclusion, the evidence from the novel and various adaptations strongly indicates that Laurie and Amy's love is genuine and mature. Their shared interests, independent development of feelings, and positive support for each other make their marriage a successful and loving partnership. Whether this love from Laurie for Amy is enough to make fans of Jo happy remains a matter of personal interpretation, but the affection is indeed real and deep.