Do Authors Have Full Control Over Their Characters and Plots?

The age-old question that plagues many a writer is whether they have full control over the characters and plots they create. It’s a topic that sparks debate among authors and readers alike. Some believe they have complete control, while others found that their characters start to take on a life of their own. So, where does the truth lie?

A Balance of Control and Character Autonomy

The truth is that it's a bit of both. Authors definitely have control over the overall plot and story progression, but the characters play a significant role in shaping the narrative. As an experienced author puts it, 'You have control over the plot and events, and the personality of a character, but when you create a character with specific qualities, such as being shy and quiet, that kind of writes itself on how they should act and speak.'

Developing the qualities and characteristics of a character persuades their actions, tone, and motives. This interplay creates a dynamic relationship between the author's intent and the characters' autonomy. Often, the more you delve into your character development, the more natural and organic your story becomes.

Characters Taking Over the Story

Some authors have experienced instances where their characters started to take over the story. When this happens, it can be both frustrating and exhilarating. As one writer explains, 'When they refuse to do what I want, I need to listen to them. They may have a better idea.' In many cases, trust your characters and let them lead the narrative where they want to go. The story might unfold in unexpected ways, but often, these unexpected turns can create the most compelling narratives.

Character vs. Plot-Centric Writing

The relationship between characters and plots is heavily influenced by the perspective of the writer. Some stories are plot-driven, where the character's actions are simply the means to an end. In such cases, the characters serve as vectors for the story, with their actions and conversations driven by the plot. For instance, in a hypothetical story where a sweets cart appears in a train, the cart's presence is purely a setup for later plot developments.

On the other hand, some stories are character-driven, where the narrative is shaped by the characters' personalities and development. These narratives are rooted in the protagonists' personal journeys and motivations, making their actions the crux of the story. A famous example of this is Harry Potter series. The books range from being heavily plot-focused (like Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (Book 1)) to character-focused (like Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (Book 2)).

Case Study: The Harry Potter Series

The Harry Potter series provides a perfect example of how character and plot can interplay. Books 1, 4, and 7 are heavily plot-focused, with the storyline driven by events that force the narrative forward. For example, the sweets cart on the train in Book 1 serves as a setup for later plot points, such as the discovery of Dumbledore's card.

In contrast, Books 2, 3, and 6 are character-focused, with the plot evolving from the characters' personal traits and actions. The development of Ginny's friendship with Harry in Chamber of Secrets, for instance, is driven by Draco Malfoy's personality. The curiosity of Harry and his quest for knowledge in the later volumes drive the action in the second and third books.

Book 5 is a mix of both. Some parts, such as the development of the Dumbledore Army and the growing connection between Harry and Voldemort, are more character-focused. Other parts, like the Ministry take-over and the prophecy, are more plot-driven.

Ultimately, whether an author has full control over their characters and plots depends on the storytelling focus. When the story is driven by the characters, they will often carve their own path, while in plot-driven narratives, the characters are mere tools to advance the storyline.

So, the next time you find yourself staring at a blank page, remember that your characters might have something to say. Trust them and allow them to take the reins. Your story just might become more engaging and dynamic in the process.