Literature
Creating or Building on an Idea: Which is Easier for Novel Writing?
Creating or Building on an Idea: Which is Easier for Novel Writing?
As a new author who has been working on their first draft for over a year and has already written 90,000 words, the question of whether it's easier to build on an idea or to create one from scratch haunts me. This essay delves into the process of novel writing and explores the ease of creating an idea versus building on an existing concept, concluding with personal preferences and reasons why.
The Process of Novel Writing
New authors often face the challenge of starting a novel. I started with an idea of inventing a new technology to find and colonize a new planet, but with a twist on the traditional values. This proved relatively easy for me, as I am what some call a 'pants writer,' which means I don't stick to a detailed outline and jump from one idea to the next. However, I do recognize the value of outlining and plan to attempt it someday.
Creating an idea from scratch can be daunting, especially when staring at a blank page with a blank mind. It requires a significant amount of imagination and creativity. The idea can come from everyday observations or even a simple article, such as 'Scientists practice communicating with aliens by chatting to whales.' This minor observation can spark a wealth of ideas and drive the story forward, making the work more engaging and meaningful.
Building on an Idea: An Easier Route?
Building on an idea can be a smoother and more straightforward process. It provides a solid foundation that can be shaped and expanded, allowing the author to tell a more cohesive and compelling story. For instance, my idea of a new technology to find and colonize a new planet offers a clear direction and a purpose for the story. This concept can be further developed, creating a detailed world and a unique setting that will engage readers.
One of the benefits of building on an idea is that it allows for a structured approach. An author can start with a character, a setting, or a conflict, and then expand from there. This method can be particularly helpful for those who value organization and prefer to have a blueprint before diving into the writing process.
The Role of Outlines
While building on an idea can be easier, it's important to recognize the role of outlines. An outline can guide the author through the narrative, ensuring that the story remains coherent and well-structured. Outlining can help in organizing the plot, characters, and themes, making the writing process more manageable and efficient.
Some authors find that having a basic outline helps them stay on track and maintain a sense of direction. However, for those who prefer a more spontaneous writing style, the lack of a rigid structure can be liberating. It allows for more flexible storytelling and room for unexpected twists and turns. The key is finding a balance that suits the author's creative process.
Personal Preference
In my own writing experience, I find that a combination of building on an idea and a structured approach works best. While I have an initial idea, I still benefit from outlining some key points and character developments. This hybrid approach allows me to leverage the strengths of both methods.
The challenge of starting a novel lies in the initial spark of an idea. Whether it comes from a simple observation or a complex concept, it is the driving force behind the story. For me, the ease of building on an idea comes from the initial guidance it provides, while still allowing for creative freedom.
Conclusion
The ease of creating or building on an idea depends on the author's personal preference and the nature of the initial inspiration. For some, an idea may seem daunting, while for others, it can be a springboard for creative expression. Whether you choose to write with a pen in hand or a plan in mind, the journey of novel writing is full of discovery and learning.
By embracing both the thrill of building on an idea and the structure of outlining, authors can craft compelling stories that resonate with readers. Striking this balance is key to achieving success in the realm of novel writing, as it allows for both creativity and coherence in the narrative.
So, the next time you sit down to write a novel, consider whether you prefer to start with a solid foundation or to let your imagination run wild. The choice is yours, but remember, the process is as much about the journey as it is the destination.