Character Analysis of Commander Lawrence from 'The Handmaid's Tale'

The character of Commander Lawrence in The Handmaid's Tale presents a nuanced and complex persona, one that doesn’t fit neatly into conventional stereotypes. His role in the series is multifaceted, embodying both admirable and controversial traits. Let’s explore Lawrence's character and his motivations in the context of an oppressive society.

Complex Intellect and Ethical Ambiguity

Commander Lawrence is a highly intelligent and passionate individual who has a deep understanding of society and its dynamics. He was a key figure in the creation of Gilead and holds a significant place in its intellectual landscape. His role as a husband and father to June provides a human dimension to the narrative, making him more than just a cold and calculating individual. However, his ethical ambiguity is evident, as his actions and decisions often blur the lines between right and wrong.

Making Tough Choices and Intellectual Challenge

Lawrence’s motivations largely stem from a desire to revitalize the population while adhering to the societal framework of Gilead. This noble intention frequently leads to morally challenging decisions. For instance, his relationship with his wife Emily is notable because he genuinely cares for her, yet his commitment to the societal goals often puts her in peril. When given the opportunity to do harm to her, he chooses not to, reflecting his complex nature. This decision showcases his inner struggle and the ethical dilemmas he faces every day.

Eccentricity and Motivations

Lawrence's eccentricity is not random; it serves a purpose. He actors his sexism and other eccentricities to maintain a certain persona, which allows him to operate more freely within the society. His desire to be an enigma and his admiration for his own designs that solve the fertility crisis are integral to his character. He also avoids social interaction due to his disdain for most people but enjoys having his ego stoked, indicating a deep-seated need for recognition and approval. These traits make him a multifaceted and intriguing character.

Relationships and Future Plans

The relationship between Commander Lawrence and June holds immense interest, especially for viewers eager to see how two conflicting forces might interweave. Although Lawrence is not a villain in the traditional sense, his moral ambiguity and his presence in a sociopolitical net pave the way for a unique dynamic. His relationship with June might either develop into an alliance or conflict, which could significantly impact the outcome of the narrative.

Psychological and Sociopolitical Analysis

From a psychological perspective, Commander Lawrence can be compared to individuals recruited by the Soviet Union as spies. He is an intelligent narcissist who views problems through an intellectual lens. The societal crisis in Gilead presented by the fertility decline is the ultimate intellectual challenge for him, much like how various crises were challenges for spies. He sees the crisis as not just a social or economic problem but a grand intellectual puzzle that needs solving.

Lawrence's bookshelf is indicative of his long-term research and analysis. His belief in the theocratic governance as a solution to the fertility crisis is well-founded, as historical examples (like the spike in births under the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt or the higher birth rate in Georgia during its religious revival) support his theory. His approach to societal collapse involves a return to more traditional roles and structures, which he sees as a means to survive and progress.

Ethics and Morality

Lawrence’s ethical stance is perhaps one of the most complex elements of his character. While other characters, such as the psychopaths and sociopaths in power, use force, he provides a moral and legal framework for them, allowing them to justify their actions. This creates a form of legitimacy and compliance that they would not have otherwise. His role is essential in maintaining the integrity of their moral architecture.

Despite the ethical implications, Lawrence remains deeply invested in his project, his role, and his legacy. He believes that his actions are necessary for the survival of the future, viewing his intellectual endeavors as a noble cause. His desire to be seen as a hero, the architect of a future with a thriving population, fuels his motivations and actions. This makes his character all the more compelling, as viewers are left to ponder the ethical and moral implications of his choices.

Conclusion

To summarize, Commander Lawrence is a highly complex and intriguing character in The Handmaid's Tale. His multifaceted nature, ethical ambiguity, and motivations provide a rich narrative layer that engages the audience. Whether seen as a symbol of intellectual prowess or a leader with questionable morals, his character invites deep reflection on the nature of power, ethics, and survival in an oppressive society.