Authors' Perspective on Their Work Being Labeled as Literature

When discussing the categorization of literary works, a common question arises: How do authors feel about their works being labeled as literature instead of fiction or non-fiction? This question is often complex and multi-faceted due to the nuanced nature of the terms used, such as 'literature,' 'fiction,' and 'non-fiction.'

The Evolution of Categorization in Literature

Traditional categorization in literature and creative writing divides the field into fiction, non-fiction, and sometimes includes creative non-fiction, which acts as a bridge between the two. However, the term 'literature' is not a genre but a descriptor for written works that possess serious artistic merit.

Literature: According to the Oxford Languages, literature refers to 'written works especially those considered of superior or lasting artistic merit.'

Fiction: A fiction is a deliberately fabricated account of something, or, more generally, it refers to a literary work based on imagination rather than fact, such as novels, short stories, and novellas.

Non-fiction: Non-fiction is prose writing that is informative or factual rather than fictional. Examples include history, scientific works, self-help books, and journalism.

The Nuance of 'Instead'

The key to understanding the distinction between these categories lies in the word 'instead,' as used in the initial question. The categories fiction, non-fiction, and creative non-fiction are not mutually exclusive or interchangeable. Just as you cannot say that a food is 'fruit instead of apples or oranges,' you cannot say that literature is 'instead of fiction or non-fiction.'

Therefore, the classification of literature is distinct and does not replace or compete with fiction and non-fiction, but rather stands as a separate, high standard of artistic achievement.

Recognition and Merit

Literature holds a unique place in the literary universe. For any thoughtful or creative writer, the label of 'literature' is undoubtedly a high compliment. It signifies that their work has earned an esteemed position among those that are recognized for their artistic merit.

It is important to note that the recognition of a work as 'literature' does not imply that all fiction or non-fiction works are not worthy. Many works in genres like science fiction, fantasy, and horror, once considered mere entertainments, are now recognized for their literary merit. Similarly, non-fiction works might be brilliantly executed but are not necessarily considered literature by the literary community.

The Personal Impact on Authors

For authors, the recognition of their work as literature can be a significant validation of their efforts and the quality of their craft. It not only elevates their status in the literary community but also provides readers with a clear indication of the value and depth of the work.

Many authors would be thrilled to have their works recognized as literature because it signifies a level of artistic and intellectual rigor that is often associated with this label. It reflects a higher standard of quality and timeless value.

Conclusion

In summary, the categorization of literature, fiction, and non-fiction is a complex and nuanced process. While the initial question suggests a compete or competing relationship between these categories, it is more appropriate to view them as hierarchical in terms of artistic merit. For authors, having their work labeled as literature is a significant accolade indicating the high quality and lasting value of their writing.