Ancestry and Succession in Westeros: If Robin Arryn Dies, Who Inherits the Lordship of the Vale?

Westeros is a land ruled by heritage and law, with a complex web of bloodlines and allegiances. In the world of George R.R. Martin's epic novel series, A Song of Ice and Fire, and its adaptation, Game of Thrones, the concept of succession plays a crucial role. This article delves into the implications of Robin Arryn’s potential demise and examines who would inherit the Lordship of the Vale if he were to pass away without an heir.

The Current Situation of the Lordship of the Vale

The current Lord of the Vale is Robin Arryn, a prominent character in the series. Robin, however, does not have a known heir. Succession laws are often based on bloodlines and proximity to the deceased. In Westeros, a child typically inherits the title, followed by the closest living relative.

Robin Arryn's Potential Heir

Considering the scenario where Robin Arryn dies without inheriting an heir, the question arises as to who would stand in line next. The articles and show episodes have focused on Robin Arryn as the next Lord of the Vale, with no mention of an established heir. Therefore, we can assume that the line of succession would look at the next closest relative to the Arryn family.

Harry Hardyng: The Longest Genetic Distance

Theoretically, if Robin Arryn dies without an heir, one of the closest living relatives to the Arryn family would inherit the title. According to the books, the next in line would be Harry Hardyng, often referred to as "Harry the Heir." Harry Hardyng is the great-nephew of Jon Arryn, a key character in the series. His lineage traces back to Jon Arryn’s younger sister and her youngest daughter:

Grandfather: Jon Arryn Mother: Younger sister of Jon Arryn Son: Harry Hardyng

Currently, Harry Hardyng is a ward of Lady Waynwood, overseeing the Waynwood heirlooms while preparing for his lordship.

The Show's Take on Inheritance

Turn to the TV show adaptation, the heirs and succession of the Vale are portrayed similarly. If Robin Arryn were to die without an heir, it is likely that one of the Vale Lords would inherit. This would be anyone who is most closely related to the Arryn family. In the show, Jon Arryn, as Roborick Arryn's stepfather, holds the title of Lord of the Vale.

The Importance of Proximity in Succession

Succession in Westeros often hinges on blood ties and proximity to the deceased lord. This is why Harry Hardyng, a relative with clear bloodline ties to the Arryns, would be the most sensible choice. His lineage makes him the closest living relative without an established claim to a rival title or territory.

Other Potential Inheritors

While Harry Hardyng is the most immediate heir, there could be other potential successors with closer ties. These might include:

Roborick Arryn's siblings, if any, who might claim the title. If there are any quasi-relatives or vassals of the Arryns who have a more direct bloodline or through marriages.

The Lord of the Vale's Responsibilities

Regardless of who inherits the title, the role of the Lord of the Vale involves political and military leadership, ensuring the safety and prosperity of the Vale, and navigating the intricate political landscape of Westeros. This includes managing the economy, overseeing law and order, and defending the region against threats from external and internal sources.

Consequences of Robin Arryn's Death

The death of Robin Arryn without a known heir could lead to several outcomes:

Stability: If Harry Hardyng is accepted as the next lord, the transition would be relatively smooth, preserving the current stability. Conflict: Alternatively, if there were disputes over inheritance, this could lead to power struggles and political intrigue, destabilizing the region. Test of Character: The potential heir, whether it be Harry Hardyng or someone else, would face a significant test in proving their worth and capability to lead the Vale.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the lordship of the Vale is heavily influenced by bloodlines and succession laws in Westeros. If Robin Arryn dies without an heir, the closest living relative to the Arryn family would inherit the title. The current theory is that Harry Hardyng, the great-nephew of Jon Arryn, would become the next Lord of the Vale. However, the true outcome would depend on the show's narrative and the decision-makers within the storyline.

Understanding these complexities and the roles within the political landscape of Westeros adds depth and suspense to the ongoing saga of A Song of Ice and Fire and its adaptation, Game of Thrones.