Alternate Endings to The Great Gatsby: Exploring New Themes and Narratives

What if the story of Jay Gatsby were to have a different end?

The novel The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a timeless exploration of the American Dream, love, and social class. While the original ending has been widely debated, what if it could have turned out differently?

Gatsby Survives

Instead of being killed by George Wilson, Gatsby manages to survive the confrontation. Choosing to leave West Egg behind, he starts anew in another city, perhaps in California. This new beginning allows Gatsby to reinvent himself without the shadow of his past. His journey then focuses on themes of redemption and the possibility of change.

Daisy Chooses Gatsby

In a different twist, Daisy, after realizing the emptiness of her life with Tom, decides to leave him for Gatsby. Together, they escape to start a new life somewhere far from the chaos of their current existence. This ending highlights the themes of love and the pursuit of happiness, albeit in an idealized manner.

Nick Takes Action

Disillusioned by the events that transpired, Nick Carraway takes matters into his own hands. He confronts Tom Buchanan directly, leading to a public scandal that tarnishes Tom's reputation. As a result, Gatsby and Daisy can finally find a semblance of happiness together. This ending emphasizes themes of justice and the power of voices speaking up against social injustices.

The American Dream Unraveled

In a more cynical twist, Gatsby's death sparks a public investigation into the corruption behind his wealth. This leads to a societal reckoning about the American Dream, with Nick becoming a journalist who writes a critical expose on the decadence of the East Egg elite. He highlights the illusion of success and the moral decay of society.

Myrtle's Perspective

The story could shift to focus on Myrtle Wilson's experiences, exploring her dreams and aspirations. After Gatsby's death, she rises to prominence in a different way, perhaps by writing a memoir about her life with Tom and the Buchanans. This perspective sheds light on the struggles of the lower class and the harsh realities of their lives.

A Twist of Fate

Another alternate ending sees Gatsby arrested before he can be killed, leading to a high-profile trial. Secrets about the Buchanans come to light, and Daisy is forced to confront her own complicity in Myrtle's death. This ending explores themes of accountability and the consequences of privilege.

Each of these alternate endings offers a unique lens through which to examine the themes of love, ambition, social class, and the American Dream that Fitzgerald weaves throughout the novel.