The Best Miss Marple Actors: Julia McKenzie and Geraldine McEwan

When discussing the best Miss Marple actors, a few names stand out, not the least of which are Geraldine McEwan and Julia McKenzie. However, when compared, it becomes evident that Julia McKenzie is undoubtedly a more fitting portrayal of Agatha Christie's beloved detective. This article will explore why one actress seems more authentic than the other, with a particular focus on their performances and the role's original concept.

Historical Context and Miss Marple

Miss Marple, a fictional character created by Agatha Christie, has captivated audiences for decades. Agatha Christie developed Miss Marple as an elderly, seemingly gentle, and unassuming housekeeper who uses her keen observational skills to solve complex murders. The novels often depict her as wielding a razor-sharp mind and an extensive knowledge of human nature.

The Evolution of Miss Marple on Television

The first portrayal of Miss Marple on television was by the legendary Joan Hickson, a choice that Agatha Christie herself approved. Hickson's Miss Marple was a quintessential old lady living in the 1920s, with a cozy cottage garden and a loyal maid. Her portrayal captured the essence of Agatha Christie's original character, blending authenticity with a depth of character that made her both relatable and formidable.

Following Hickson, Geraldine McEwan and Julia McKenzie took on the role in later adaptations. Julie McKenzie's performance in the first series was praised for being closer to Hickson's in terms of charm and authenticity, although not without her own unique touch. However, the portrayal of Miss Marple by Geraldine McEwan fell short of expectations.

Julia McKenzie: A Closer Fit to Agatha Christie's Vision

Julia McKenzie’s portrayal of Miss Marple is considered closer to the original Agatha Christie's vision. While Geraldine McEwan's character was criticized for being overly smug and self-satisfied, McKenzie's performance offered a subtler and more believable interpretation of the character. Her portrayal was both approachable and formidable, making Miss Marple relatable while maintaining her sharp intellect.

McKewn's attempt at portraying the elderly detective came across as more forced and less believable. Her character appeared too smug and self-satisfied, which is contrary to the character’s typical image of being mild-mannered and unassuming. It is possible that this portrayal was influenced by the writers or directors, or both.

Conclusion

While both Geraldine McEwan and Julia McKenzie have attempted to bring Agatha Christie's Miss Marple to life, Julia McKenzie’s performance is generally considered the most authentic and fitting portrayal. Her character closely mirrors that of Joan Hickson, who was Agatha Christie's preferred choice for the role. Despite a few critics considering other actresses (such as Helen Hayes and Margaret Rutherford) as memorable, Jane McKewn’s portraying stands out as a significant deviation from Agatha Christie's original vision.